Wait ? So she's not just random person with the same face ?
Oh I thought it was a common knowledge. Yes she was not a random person . She is the person.
So why'd she left her baby ??
Not really. And there's some errors in your comments. FL's circumstances doesn't make sense in general bc author uses magic bullshit to make us accept stuff even if they don't make sense logically and objectively.
The current FL is not the wife in terms of their body. She ONLY HAVE THE WIFE'S MEMORIES. Losing her virginity a second time and Duke mentioning FM being younger that how he remembers is proof that FL is the younger version of the wife = This FL didn't married and gave birth. The protagonist is the regressed version of the wife. Arguably the wife disappear and only her memories is left.
They explain this more in the novel that when she gave birth and had a chance to go back, both body, mind and time regressed to how she was before she got isekaid.
The wife after returning to her world and regressed back in time and body. The Duke's father asked him to tell everyone the wife died. I haven't read the last chapter of the novel yet but the latest one I read, it was implied that the father of the Duke did not approve of the wife because she's human and and used her only to bear them an heir. Who knows maybe she was also threatened by the father of the Duke.
Thus they implied that the behind the Duke's back and in the shadows, the father prob told the wife she was only wanted for an heir and not believe the Duke's affection ergo it is much easier for her to let go of them.
As for why she left them. The current female lead foreshadow it already: she grew up conditioned to be a responsible person. Plus her last parent is dying and have only her for support.
Take these into account and we can tell she chose to go back and leave because 1) she wasn't fully welcomed by the Duke's family 2) for her it is irresponsible to leave the way she did 3) her responsibility was first before her responsibility with to husband/kid for timeline reason.
Even now it's the same... FL wants to go back first of all to take care of her parents. Reason why her deal consent to being a sex slave for the Duke literally guarantee only her return.
First of all, you need to add a spoiler tag or at least warn that there’s a spoiler ahead in your comment.
Second, I don’t understand what’s wrong with my comment. I’m currently reading the novel now, days after I commented that out of impatience, and I can say for sure that the other isekai’d boi she was with is a third party.
In fact, **SPOILER AHEAD**
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
He doesn’t even care about her and actually likes Rose instead, because in his POV Rose is much more beautiful than the FL (he doesn’t care if she spreads her legs to gain information for his benefit). So yeah. It’s basically picking a “better” trash. One trash looks good but is actually not worth looking at; the other trash clings but at least is worth something.
I just knew this madf*cking author would use this type of cliché to make it easy for readers to cheer for the Marquis route instead.
Third, you need to improve your reading comprehension. I didn’t say things make sense or that what the ML did was right. In fact, I said IT’S A MATTER OF PERSPECTIVE. The current boyfriend is the third wheel.
The idea in this novel is crazy, but it is crazy interesting, and people trying to put together things to make illogical things logical is just how the brain works.
Yikes. Take your own advice lmao. I think you missed my point completely... I never even questioned the boyfriend being trash and a third party but ok. See what you wanna see I guess. If you deluded yourself reading me writing the boyfriend is not a third party or trash go ahead in delululand.
my comment is not even spoiler either since the webtoon have caught to the instances/proof I mentioned.
Yikes. Pride really got you, ain’t it? Why comment your spoiler then? You said "Not really. And there’s some errors in your comments.” and then started going on about "FL is not the wife in terms of their body." "Regress" this and that. You’re just trying to wash your hands clean after dropping a major spoiler.
What? Her time and body regress. And? What’s the big ERROR you’re talking about then? She is STILL HIS WIFE. They have a CHILD. What kind of mental gymnastics is your point then? Just because the FL’s body and time regress while everyone else keeps moving forward doesn’t magically erase the time she spent with the people she left behind, or the 11 years or so of them waiting for her to come back.
For fcksake. A child who shares her DNA is proof those days exist.
Some people seriously need to learn what ACCOUNTABILITY even means.
Just like your comments filled with spoilers. I’ve read up to chapter 42 of the novel and none of the spoilers you casually dumped were mentioned yet.
You’re out here throwing spoilers left and right just to feel superior, without even thinking about the people who will read it next. Ever heard of consideration? Basic courtesy?
As for mine, well I apologize if some readers got caught off guard. For me, everything already points to her being the actual wife. Flashbacks, the maid and butler treating her kindly, her being a spitting image of the wife, almost identical names, moles, body, mannerisms, her feelings toward him and the child, them being obsessed with her, her worrying about her bedridden mom, everything. It’s obvious.
But never did I think her body regressed. I thought maybe amnesia or her OG world and his have different timelines (like one moves faster and one slower)
But nope. Body regression. And thanks to you, I get spoiled before the dang story even reveals it. And no tag or warning at that. Well good job. You must be very proud of yourself.
Not sure, haven’t read it yet, but I’m leaning toward the conclusion that she wants to look after her bedridden mother and left the child with her husband so he would not be lonely, unlike her mother.
But who knows. "Suzzu" dropped all the MAJOR SPOILERS saying it’s related to the race, being ostracized, contract and miscommunication. Well, I don’t know, but read at your own risk.
I see whatever I write is gonna be corrected with "I read..." even when you clearly didn't. + the comment section is for people commenting on the webtoon. People reading what got uploaded. YOU'RE STRAIGHT UP LYING AT THIS POINT or you read the webtoon&novel with your eyes closed if you think what I wrote is SPOILERS. I stopped reading the novel before the garden scenes btw.. The talk about age regression and duke's father talk are some chapters after their first intercourse. You did not freaking read those chapters....
YIKES because YOU CAN'T TAKE PEOPLE CORRECTLY YOU AT ALL. You even wrote text walls in every replies, each passive aggressively insulting people and throwing your own theories and words as facts..
I'm not prideful enough to react the way....
BTW I have no intention of arguing over a garbage erotica webtoon/novel and I lowk don't give strangers online more time and attention than I should. Have a good day.
It would’ve been so simple for you to edit your comment and add a spoiler warning, yet you avoided responsibility. And since we’re talking about corrections, it’s “correcting,” not “correctly.” The correct sentence is, “You can’t take people correcting you.” Maybe sort that out before correcting others.
I honestly can’t believe I ended up in an argument with someone who didn’t even finish the story past the garden scene, yet acted like an expert and even accused others of not reading. If telling yourself that helps you sleep at night, go ahead.
Please, if your spoilers came from NovelUpdates, TikTok, Reddit, or anywhere else, keep them to yourself or at least be discreet. Don’t act like an expert while spoiling everything for others.
Lastly, yes, I don’t accept your correction because that is just your opinion. You can’t debate with me if your information came from a third party. Finish the actual story first, then correct me when you actually read it yourself. As of now, I stand by my understanding. She is still the wife regardless of the time and body regression. Svanhild is their child, and if you had read past the garden scene, you wouldn’t have even made your silly comment. At the end of the day, they are married (what the marquis does to his wife is something I don’t fully support, and the story is something I wish to understand. That's why I'm reading it.).
On the other hand,What you’re trying to do is push your own flawed interpretation as a correction to mine, and I am simply declining it because it’s illogical.
Now that I think about it, the third party here is actually the current boyfriend. The FL and the Duke were legally married and had children together. The problem is that she forgets everything and makes the current world think she died.
Don’t get me wrong, when I first read it I felt disgusted that there was NTR. Like, what the f**k, is loyalty not a trend or a thing anymore? Why do people get horny over cheating? It’s not my cup of tea. In fact, I have a soft spot for loyal characters and subordinates. But the more I think about it, it’s messy as f**k because she forgets everything, he assumes the worst, and they have zero communication like a healthy relationship should.
I feel bad for the boyfriend because he doesn’t even know the FL already has a family. I hope he doesn’t turn evil, or that they don’t make a plot twist where he does and ends up dying. Like, please, give me a break with the clichés. How miserable do they want him to end up?