.⭒☆ Historical | Romance | Fantasy Master List ☆⭒.

Tier: B-
Plot: 6
Art Style: 8
Slow Pace | Angst-ish
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 9
ML Character: ???
ML Attractiveness: ???

Summary: FL is a saintess that does everything perfectly but has a sad past of being abused by the temple. She was ousted by 4 OG MLs for not being obedient to them, and so they replaced her with a fake saintess and condemned her for being "the fake". She builds up her own power after being ousted.
Comment: N/A

Tier: B-
Plot: 7
Art Style: 8
Moderate Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 8
FL Attractiveness: 8
ML Character: 7
ML Attractiveness: 6 (redhead)

Summary: FL's parents die when she and her older sister were young, and she remembers that she was reincarnated and the plot of the story. Works hard to fix the dukedom and weed out corruption since childhood. ML (prince) requests FL as an aide and she accepts to protect her sister (OG FL). He constantly proposes
Comment: N/A

Tier: B-
Plot: 7
Art Style: 7.5
Moderate Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 6 - (she's alright)
FL Attractiveness: 7.5
ML Character: 8
ML Attractiveness: 7.5

Summary: FL is a divine beast, taking the form of a squirrel. Helps ML in his abusive household and forms bond. [Spoilers:] She can become human from absorbing magic, this plot point happens pretty soon. ML and FL are separated by war, and finds each other after.
Comment: N/A

Tier: B-
Plot: 8
Art Style: 6
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 8
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 8
ML Attractiveness: 8

Summary: There's a competition to become the heavenly emperor's wife, and the competition is broadcasted as a reality show. FL is the underdog, and catches the emperor's attention from [Spoilers:] doing well.
Comment: N/A

Tier: B-
Plot: 6
Art Style: 7
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 8
ML Character: 6
ML Attractiveness: 8.5

Summary: FL is a kid (?) that landed in another dimension in a dragon’s lair, and cooks to appease his anger. ML is a dragon (with a human form) who is lazy and just trying to sleep.
Comment: There are [Spoilers:] hints of romance, but it’s sussing me out because she looks like a kid and they never specify an age for her, so I’m going to ignore the romance. It’s adorab

Tier: C
Plot: 5
Art Style: 5
Slow Pace | Modern Setting with Historical Reference
FL Character: 5 - (bland)
FL Attractiveness: 6
ML Character: 5 - (bland)
ML Attractiveness: 6 - (boyish, clingy)

Summary: FL reincarnated from historical into modern Korea. There are espers and guides, and she's the perfect guide for ML but wants to hide it because she doesn't wanna work for the government.
Comment: N/A

Tier: C
Plot: 6
Art Style: 5
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 6.5 - (meh)
FL Attractiveness: 5
ML Character: 7
ML Attractiveness: 6.5

Summary: FL is a prominent knight captain, and ML is chasing her by joining her knight squadron as her subordinate.
Comment: I cannot for the life of me bring myself to care about the actual plot points.

Tier: C
Plot: 8.5
Art Style: 4
Slowish Pace | Angst
FL Character: 8
FL Attractiveness: 3

Summary: FL is a "chosen one" summoned into a "villainess"'s body, has the power to stave off the madness of many male characters. [Spoilers:] ML(?) is a fucking controlling asshole imprisoning her.
Comment: Subverted my expectations, good on them. Artstyle is still ass though.

Tier: C
Plot: 8
Art Style: 4
Slowish Pace | ??
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 4
ML Character: 6
ML Attractiveness: 6

Summary: FL is from a fallen noble family, only studying at the academy due to a scholarship for her grades. Missing an exam made her lose the scholarship so ML funds her tuition to get her to stay, but she has to tutor him.
Comment: N/A