beta
Tier: C
Plot: 6
Art Style: 7
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 6
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 7
Summary: FL is a reincarnator in the body of a powerless duchess who is shunned and mocked by high society for her meekness, and unloved by her husband the duke ML. FL starts making and sharing tea.
Comments: Artists need to stop making blonde so yellow. Feels like a tea fanfic with a lacklustre romance. ML is just an allegedly hot wallet, an accessory to the FL.
Tier: C
Plot: 5
Art Style: 8.5
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 6
FL Attractiveness: 4-8
ML Character: 7
ML Attractiveness: 8
Summary: FL asks ML to help her exercise.
Comment: There’s a total of ONE plot point that does not serve the romance. There’s really not much to the story, so read it if you just like pure romance fluff, I guess.
Tier: C
Plot: 4
Art Style: 6
Slow Pace | Fluff | Bad Translation
FL Character: 8
FL Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL is reincarnated into a helpless countess’s body as the apostle of the god of beauty. It’s a gacha game style territory management story with handsome guys in the background.
Comment: Not much plot or romance, but a fun idle read watching her succeed and gain power. It’s a fun gimmick though. Also shoutout for being the first historical manhwa I read .
Tier: C
Plot: 7
Art Style: 6
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5
FL Attractiveness: 6
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL is a reincarnator who gets married to the prince ML when they were both children. Her character was meant to be the villainess so she plans to divorce him when they grow up.
Comment: The least interesting characters in the story are the main leads. Every other character is much more compelling than they are. ML reminds me of Yoonbum.
Tier: C
Plot: 7
Art Style: 7
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 8
ML Character: ???
ML Attractiveness: ???
Summary: FL raises three kids who are the OG villains at an orphanage and protects instead of abuse them. Then we see them grow up and each achieve amazing things.
Comment: Terrified at the possibility that the CHILDREN she raised would be the love interests.
Tier: C
Plot: 7
Art Style: 5
Slow Pace | Angst-ish
FL Character: 8
FL Attractiveness: 6
ML Character: 5
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: [Spoilers:] FL and ML both remember past life as guide and esper. ML mistreated his wife, FL back in Korea and tries to win her over in the current world.
Comment: N/A
Tier: C
Plot: 6
Art Style: 8
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 7
Summary: FL is a slave who was a princess for 2 years, then her kingdom was defeated by ML’s army, who took her in as a slave again. Prince ML is charmed by her happy go lucky attitude despite being a slave.
Comment: Story drags after the kidnapping. ML looks like he was drawn w a diff art style first half. FL characterisation goes out the window in the last quarter.
Tier: C-
Plot: 5
Art Style: 6
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL is a reincarnator + time regressor, was a villainess, then a modern doctor, and came back to save the world with modern medical knowledge.
Comment: So many blondes. A mary sue who never fucks up, and everyone likes her after a single conversation. Any non-relative young man immediately falls for her. Conflicts are immediately resolved.
Tier: C-
Plot: 5
Art Style: 7
Slowish Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5 - (generic child FL)
Summary: FL is a child from a collateral branch of the family but is adopted by the heir. Instantly recognised as helpful. Meets other children throughout the plot that are future MLs.
Comment: Very generic, don't really care about the plot nor the characters
Messages
I like your comments