this is an illegal manga site too calm your ass down and just let people do what they want to do. no one is forcing you to read this !! :))
the hypocrisy in this comment. you’re literally reading on an illegal site yourself LOLOLOLOL. and according to your list most of those things are unofficial translations which also include “iLlEgAl ScReEnShOtS” and by feedback we meant on our cleaning and translations not anything related to the other stuff you mentioned.
and what you don't know is that i am on this site to get to know all these comics so i can go find them on the legal sites and support the authors as soon as they are licensed. i have 9 different websites and apps that i am subscribed to and where i pay for the official english translations. and where no official english translation is out, i buy the manga in physical form in japanese, and now i am studying korean just so i can go subscribe to these korean creators and support them, since not nearly enough comics get official translations on legal websites.
if you didn't want this kind of feedback, then what exactly did you want? and why did you ignore the points i bring up, as if they are not true? are you too stingy to buy your own raws? or too lazy to go find them? do you speak an ounce of korean or was i correct about the translation apps? are there not pages missing and not in order? you think you cleaned the pages? really? are you really convinced that you delivered a good product here with good means? you don't even provide links to the creator's official release site so that people whp stumble upon this shitty upload can go support the original work.
and i am not reading this anymore lmfao
they asked for feedback, i gave them mine. no one is fprcing you to read my comment either, so go along and ignore it if you don't like it
LMAOOO I LITERALLY OWN 12 OUT OF 24 OF THE CHAPTERS ON LEZHIN. I have been speaking korean for about 7 months of course I won’t be perfect and i’ll admit the translations and cleaning is iffy but I do not get these raws from illegal websites and ive been keeping up with the updates on lezhin since september LOLOLOL.
go say that to the other people who don’t upload the official link to the raws . seems like you don’t care if they have it if the translation and cleaning is to your liking.
sure jan
whats your discord ill show you proof bozo
you proved enough by using screenshots found on toonkor and newtoki instead of your own from lezhin that you claim to read it on, not being proficient enough in korean to do translating (don't get me wrong, i think what you are doing is good practice if you're really studying korean, but they don't need to be distributed when they are obviously stolen screenshots off an illegal site), not addressing my other points and trying to attack me about things you don't know anything about (like my consumption of the comics on this site and my telling or not telling other uploaders things i am telling you). not to mention that proving things to me only instead of all the readers of this comic by putting your proof in the uploads, is pointless in and of itself.
you honestly sound like a teenager by the way you are engaging here in this thread, and i am not interested in fighting with someone i don't even know or care about. just take the criticism or don't, and let's each be on our way.
for the last time. i. bought. the. chapters. from. lezhin. i offered proof on discord and now your dodging and continuing to say i stole them from tkor. what is your discord tag so I can show you PROOF that I have been purchasing the chapters since 3 days after the release date.
do you want me to show your proof that I saved them from lezhin? LOL
if you weren’t interested in fighting you would apologize for your mistake of you thinking I get and screenshot the raws from an illegal website. I already admitted to my translations and my cleaning to be iffy (like you asked before) now why don’t you just apologize for the assumption so we can be even?
To be honest you’re the one and only person that has assumed that I steal raws from an illegal website. I get a few comments saying that they are confused and the translation is weird but I have owned up to that (which i’ve said a million times now so don’t say I’m not listening to the points your making)
i will not apologize for being right and you obnoxiously trying to doge my criticism. lie to yourself and try to bend reality all you want, but i am no fool. you stole them, as proven by the watermarks and even yourself at one page, where the screenshot cuts of a speechbubble and you put an asterisk to explain that this part is missing from where you got it from. if they were your own screenshots you could easily replace them or just put the translation of what should be there in place of it. but the watermark is glaring evidence enough.
i even doubt your studying korean, since i have been studying it for not even a month and noticed obvious mistakes that change the entire meaning of everything written there. they are not even beginners mistake, they are obvious results off a translating machine. you did not translate anything here, not even a word.
as i said, try fooling yourself and maybe succeed in fooling other gullible or uninformed people on this site, but i won't be fooled by your clownery.
and i repeat, proving things to me, who isn't an inspector or holds any kind of authority in checking illegal distributions of copyrighted material, is useless. prove me i am wrong with the uploads, so everyone who sees the uploads can tell. i know you can't do that because you are a liar. a really bad and obvious one.
This is my THIRD time asking for you to give me your discord tag so I could provide proof that I saved them from the lezhin site.
a bad liar? yet you won’t let me provide proof? telling me to stop uploading because of how bad it is and then telling me to upload to give proof? make up your mind......
“trying to dodge my criticism” i’ve quoted myself THREE times agreeing to what you were saying with the points that were correct. Being INCORRECT is not critisicm so I will obviously inform you on the truth and back myself up.
did you even read our scanlations thing? I am not the only one translating, our translator hye is very fluent in korean and she helps me when I fail to understand thing. And even if that wasn’t the case I HAVE ALREADY admitted to the translations being iffy anyways for the FORTH time now.
this will be the last time i reply to your nonsense
1. i said proving anything to me in private does nothing, you should have been able to prove you are right with the uploads themselves. and since you seem to lack reading comprehension, let me tell you what i mean: the uploads you have provided so far should not have left any doubt that people like me could jump on in the comments in the first place. since you did a bad job and used bad means to do a bad job, i am saying to stop this nonsense. not that you should upload more of this nonsense. and if you were to upload more and suddenly use yoir own purchased screenshots grom lezhin, people would immediately know that you have been spewing nothing but lies so far.
2. you got the raws from here, not from lezhin: https://newtoki95.com/webtoon/8334715/%EC%B2%AD%EC%B6%98%EC%82%AC%EC%A0%95?page=2&toon=BL%2FGL
lezhin doesn't have watermarks, nor does it have cut off panels and speech bubbles. so stop trying to say otherwise, it's embarrassing.
3. you don't give the source link to support the author that you say in your credit card you want people to go support. since you yourself don't support the author, i expected nothing less :)
4. none of you is fluent in korean. you used a translation app or website, since none of the text makes sense. don't try lie about thay now, too. it's getting ridiculous.
5. you were pretending that your pride got hurt by my being the only one "accusing" you of using illegal scans from someone else off an illegal website. listen. it's not that i am the only one "making accusations", it's that i am the only one giving you feedback altogether. feedback that you yourself asked for but now feel exposed by.
i suggest you stop this circus show now, you are only making yourself look worse and worse with each comment.
The drama in this comment section is better than the manhwas at this point
three issues i have with these uploads:
-the translator obviously doesn't speak a shred of korean and is using google translate or something. none of the text makes any sense. translating is hard, and just slapping text into a dictionary app or something can hardly be called translating. wveryone can do that. the reason we don't is because it's pointless.
-the cleaner didn't even clean anything. how can you even want to pretend to be a cleaner when we literally have eyes and see that nothing is cleaned?
-you used illegal screenshots off an illegal manhwa reading site, meaning you didn't even try to support the author as compensation for illegally distributing an english version. these sites can be reached by everyone, so that's anotger case of "just because we can, we don't do it, since it's pointless" (refer to bulletpoint one). you're just stealing someone else's public screenshots that are incomplete and out of order, so no work put into that area either.
do everyone a favor and stop doing this. no need to waste your and our time with your zero-effort pretend-play like this. we are not stupid. you are not made for this. and you don't even have the decency to get your own raws for this pointless hobby project.