Responses

I prefer the daughter because the saving didn't happen one-sidedly. When MC was weak the daughter saved him now when he's strong he saved her and traveled together. Honestly the Poison girl and merchant girl wouldn't noticed MC if he were just a scribe but the Daughter saw the scribe in both his weak past as well as his current powerful self.
I hate it when all the girls he saved fall in love with him. I mean, Girl if the one who saved you were either an old man or your own men all they get are thanks. I'd rather the FL be his companion's daughter. The other girls' reason for falling in love is too shallow, unlike someone with whom he traveled with.