
The person who give you the dislike was maybe someone who is involve of that cliché Takahashi guy haha. I get what you're saying, I like broken characters too, I read the mangas that you listed and I loved them, specially "MODS", "Caste Heaven" I liked it but it was really weird that I liked it, it was creepy and I hated all the characters, but Azusa, gosh, I kept reading because of Azusa, just like in this manga I keep reading because of Toua, they're just so interesting! I don't read manga to see the frisking same thing over and over, so seeing characters like Toua is really refreshing ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ノ~
I'm just reading this because of Toua, he's the kind of interesting messed up character that intrigue me and I like to read, since I'm kind of fucked up too I sympathise with them (Just like with Shiro in "MODS" and Azusa in "Caste Heaven"). I really dislike characters like Takashi, that wishy-washy characters that you can see in every manga, and he's not that innocent as he seems to be, he went to Jirou place looking for sex, not because he wanted to have a good relationship with Toua, he was just lying, and it's obvious since he didn't put on a fight when Jirou kissed him, he was expecting it (I dislike the characters that act all innocent but they really aren't. I prefer the ones who accept they hideous side instead of hiding it with pretended innocence).
At least that's what I think.