How he prove that? He didn't prove anything yet.
Hed rather keep his family's upright reputation rather than save his own sister from the the royal family's abuse. And he would kill his sisters child and marry her into an old man of low status, again, for his family's reputation. All members of the valeztena family would.
He killed her lover(emiliano) and would kill her child, it didnt matter of they were orders, he had a choice to defend her and he chose not to.
You rly don't know anything. His family's upright position is not the real reason he killed Emiliano. He killed Emiliano for his sister to be forgiven by the royal family and their country. The country wanted her punish for cheating on their CP. The empress said to bring Ines back and have her marry the count for forgiveness. Ines knew she jeopardized her family and agreed.
He chose to defend Ines by killing Emiliano who is a stranger to him.
Both your response is all about the life when she was with Emiliano and had nothing to do with this dream. This dream was in the life when she was married to Oscar.
Its about the lives she had with both emiliano amd oscar. Two different lives and still proves the point that hes trash.
They don’t understand historical politics and that what Ines did put her family in a whole heap of trouble. Everyone wanted them punished including nobles and commoners. See, these readers think in modern lenses. They don’t understand the implications of Ines choosing to humiliate the imperial family and leaving her family in deep shit because of her actions. If she wanted to run away with a man, she should have broken her engagement first. If she couldn’t break it herself, she should’ve asked her father for help or even join a nunnery instead. Bottom line, Ines herself admits that she put her family in deep shit. So while these people here calling her family trash, Ines differs from them. They think they’re speaking for her when they ain’t. She loves her brother very much.
Trash because he cares about his sister? Your definition of trash seems off. If caring for your sister is trash then you must like siblings who don't care about their siblings.
Your reason for why he's trash makes you obvious for who you're shipping. This dream lifetime is not about whoever you're shipping. This dream is to show that Ines misunderstood her brother during this time and she is looking back at it in hindsight. It's about how she also misunderstood Carcel when looking back at him in hindsight. I said it in another comment but I'll say it here again. She never hated her brother. They had a very good relationship. She still loves him. In the life when she married Oscar, he gave her a bullet to kill Oscar. She couldn't do it bc she cared about her brother and didn't want him punished so she killed herself instead. Luciano revenge for Ines' death after that by torturing Oscar. Even in the lifetime when she married whoever you ship for, he cared about Ines. His goal was only for Ines safety. She was going to be punished by the royal family. He did what he thought was best to protect her from the hate and punishment of the royal family and their country's people. You only care about the guy you're shipping so you're not thinking about Ines.
Oh so you you think everyone has read the novel so youre basing it off as that. Sorry to say but i dont read the novel, so what im basing my comments off are through the webtoon. And i dont know what you mean by "Your reason for why he's trash makes you obvious for who you're shipping" bcs i dont even like emiliano and i have problems with carcel. Idc if ines loves her brother and vice versa, but the actions he shows(in the webtoon) are my definition of trash. Im not going to read the entirety of your response since its just spoilers for the whole goddamn series and no one gives a damn about giving a simple headsup. As a webtoon reader to a novel reader respectfully, if youre going to defend characters, why dont you think about if the person youre going to have a conversation with even knows about or even wants to know(as of now) the stuff youre going to bring up. People wouldnt just say "this character is trash" if they dont know what theyre talking about. If i knew what he had done in the novel for ines then i wouldnt call him trash.
Trash because he killed the person who gave her happiness after that demonic oliver, trash because he would kill her child who she had with said lover, trash bcs hed let her stay in that abusive relationship and tolerate the abuse until he had a plan, or until she kills herself. If my sister was in an abusive relationship and she had the courage to tell me, then you better believe id taker her with me right then and there. Again, why dont you think about how much i know about this story, and dont just think everybody read novel or spoilers. Yall wont let people have their own opinions bcs you know more istg. Yall are manga readers to anime watchers fr. Let people who only read the webtoon enjoy the story, if you read the novel and know what happens and you see people shitting on ur faves then that sucks for you but let the webtoon progress and youll watch those same opinions change.
I thought i liked luciano but he just keeps proving that hes also trasg like every other men in their country