I think the only reason why the story has plot holes is because the author only want to focus on the romance, not their pasts. I would love to see a story of the original Haley. I want him to have a separate story where he also reincarnated into a different body and lived happily ever after there.
Haley was just a kid, they destroyed that child's childhood and use his looks so that his relatives could buy stupid cars, house and bags. What do you expect if a kid who I don't know maybe 7yrs old!! Would grow up to be without guidance from his parents.
I think the only reason why the story has plot holes is because the author only want to focus on the romance, not their pasts. I would love to see a story of the original Haley. I want him to have a separate story where he also reincarnated into a different body and lived happily ever after there.