
Hahahahaha... ahhh..idk what spoilers you read, but ig they weren't all right? That piece of shit... remembers EVERYTHING!! Did you seriously expect him to redeem himself if he knew? Or feel even the slightest bit remorse for what he did?! Hah! This bastard is so obsessed with ines..that he'll still make the same choices no matter how many lives he lived.
You do know this is ines's 4th life, not 3rd right?
He remembers Ines's very first life that even ines herself doesn't remember..and he took advantage of it. If ines knew, she wouldn't have fallen for oscar or even marry him in her 2nd life. (╬ ̄皿 ̄)

And about him defending his fiancee..idk why he did that. But don't be fooled. Maybe he's just being more careful in this life after what happened in his previous lives. If i was him, i wouldn't even dare go near ines, but look at him! Still hovering around her. Idk if he's thick skinned or he doesn't fear for his life anymore..sheesh.

Damn, chill out people. What's with the aggressiveness?
StoryofMinglan - until now i think i didn't came across at sth that would hint that he remembers so idk, and i think when he said that he was saying it because of their life since they were kids. As far as i can remember she always ignored him or didn't give him the respect as the future crown prince. So, i actually don't know.
Nelcy- i didn't thought that he would redeem himself but i thought that he would do sth different as to at least try win her over. As i said i'm into drama these days, it wouldn't be interesting if he actually did the same things like in their previous lives.

Animegirl, I can see how you would think that but remember her own brother and waiting lady has never seen her like this either. Remember also Ines said that Dolores wasn’t scared of her. She was the only little girl who fearlessly approached her. The whole Mendoza arc is supposed to highlight how much Ines has changed. She’s never behaved like this before and that’s why Oscar’s comment is a big hint that he has memories. Isabela, her MIL, also said Ines had shut herself up since a little girl. So it’s really true that Ines has only now become more like her old self since living with Carcel in Calztela. Remember that important image of her old self meeting her current self during the flashback to hunting with her brother and Carcel at 14 years old.

There was hint during their wedding that he remembers. He was talking to Carcel as if he was teaching him how to act as someone who has married before.
Ch16
Oscar: I imagine you must want to chain her to your side at all times, but I doubt that will make for a happy marriage.
Carcel: What would an unwed man know about marriage anyway?
Oscar: There are some things you can just tell, even without having experienced them yourself.
Oscar experienced it and Ines ran away with Emiliano after so in this life, he thinks letting her be with Carcel for a bit is just letting her be free until she returns to him.
Since i'm so into drama these days, i wonder how it would be if the crown prince also remembered his lives. Wouldn't it be so interesting? I wonder how he'd react after knowing what he did to Ines. He's also quite reserved in this life from what've seen so far and defended his wife even (i was shocked at this lol). But i guess from all the spoilers i came across he won't... what a shame actually.