Huuuuuuuu

Slaves weren’t just black people, it was lots more… like whites, blacks ofc, natives, etc.

Girl I'm not gonna have this debate, but I said black cause black slavery in the 1800s was about how the black race was a lesser then species. Slavery before then was about being apart of the losing country or having debt. I'm saying black slaves because in this fantasy world they believe the animal-human creatures are lesser then beings to be controlled or put done. Not because they are apart of a losing nation. Sorry i didnt clarify i forgot white people feel bad about the atrocities, they did so much that they liked to deflect and say that every race was a slave argument knowing that it was a different type of slavery and mentality when they were slaves compared to the 1800s in the Americas. To belittle the struggle that african americans face now and back then. But thanks for the lesson I didn't need.

Slaves weren't just black ppl you realize that right? Lmao

I'll give you tye benefit of the doubt you didn't read my fucking reply. But I have a question why does it matter if I put " black slaves" or just "slaves" cause I'm getting hate for one fucking word. It's also Crazy how I got to give a history lesson to people that are trying to "educate" me. And explain why I type one fucking word.

The world history does not revolve around USA. It is sad what happened to black people but slaves were and are treated less than a dirt on a ground everywhere- it's just pop culture and big budget originates from USA so it's easier to give voice to this group specifically and silence all the others that went through similar experience. Also you lost the moment you start calling people names - that shows you lack any argument to back up your comment.

I think korea in general isn't anti imperial , so authors would have rose tinted views of aristocracy . Your anger about slavery is valid . I think people don't know enough history to know how bad it was . Like they used to eat slaves and call themselves nobels. I also agree with the fact that it wasn't just black people that were slaves , different ethnic groups were also enslaved due to aristocracy. That is not to invalidate the struggles of black inslaved people , think people forget it's not just a common struggle but the common cause , which was the Class difference and how the ruling class didn't see humanity to those of lower status. My point being in stories , like these the world building and the understanding of history is never the priority. Hence why you clearly see the cracks in who we are supposed to see as the " good guys" . And how moreoften than not commoners and those who are half blood are villains . It is the lack of understanding of the common folk struggles and the over aggrandizing of rich people . The koreans society do love their cheabols , as most common folk think they are closer to billionaire than actual other common folk. So it's understandable that it leaves an icky taste in your mouth. But I think I enjoy theses comics because when you come to a shifty generic corpo establishment for food , I don't expect gourmet . Its only ment to be romantic generic corpo shit that sells . Very rarely will you see a well made world ,story, character etc . All which is cohesively made and well crafted story. As they main purpose is to sell slop people regurgitate and enjoy . Anyways have a nice day

There was no argument in my reply I am asking genuine questions and in the first reply i talked about i was making connections to my understanding of 1800s slavery in the America's to the story. I explained my thought process the idea of black slaves in the Americas being slaves because "they are lesser then beings" i connected that to the story. Also I NEVER called anyone names if you are talking about the "girl" that's her username cause I first didn't know how to reply properly. I'll make it clear i know there are different types of slaves however my connections in my understanding of from the point of view of the 1800s slaves in america. Also no one is giving me examples of different area of slavery where they had the same mindset of a whole race is lesser then it's mostly about a country losing the war , debt or other cercomstance and yes the slaves were treated bad ( like property) but it wasn't hate from there features it was " I own you " mentality. And once African American were " freed" in America they were believed to be lesser than beings that should not be mixed in with the whites. I understand that I'm not bringing light to others struggles and also not bringing light to to all forms over slavery but it's not my job and never will be. I'm making connections based on my knowledge to a webtoon. I'm just not understanding why I'm getting hate. Cause again it's not my job to talk about struggles that I'm not educated on. Nor should I be expected to. I just don't understand why everybody is hung up on why I'm only making connections on one type of slavery that I am actually very vastly knowledged on again. This is my correlation and my connections to a story. And my opinion so I'm allowed to talk about something that I'm educated on. And I don't need to bring up the struggles of things that I'm not educated on.
Cause I have no place to. I think i'm just hung up on the fact that people are on my ass about what I make my connections on.

I understand and I am sorry that you are getting heated messages but people from other regions will call any other person out for highlighting only USA's problems.
As for example: Slavic people in middle ages, word Slave comes from the word Slavic. Group of people persecuted purely on origin (there are multiple Slavic countries). They were considered property and not even human.
You are allowed to have an opinion and no one is questioning it, the way you only highlighted one group like it's the only one deserving mentioning seems to be a problem. If you just said slavery, periodt I think many people would agree with you like one commenter below my previous comment as they are better versed on Korean mindset than I am.

I understand your point about the depiction of Black people as lesser beings in the 1800s being particularly horrible and disturbing. For clarity in possible future discussions I recommend you specify the time period you’re referring to, as the history of slavery is quite broad and has involved lots of different groups throughout time. And it seems you’re assuming I’m white based on my comment? I’m sorry to tell you this but I’m not, I’m a proud Filipino and Mexican.
So just be clearer next time, yes I agree it was horrible but not everybody is belittling African Americans, it’s just the truth. As crazy as it seems lots of people don’t know history and tend to think just black people were enslaved.. which Isn't true (obviously) .

I’m not great with words but I hope you understand what I’m trying to get at.

*Note - You didn’t have to be apart of a losing country to become a slave, it was actually mostly criminals that the country’s (That they came from -usually-) sold off

And I’m also very uncomfortable with these kinds of tropes in manhwas, I wish they would avoid it.. but it’s whatever.

And I seen your other reply, your not getting “Hate” it’s just a miscommunication on both parts, there’s no need to get angry.

Very well said!
I agree with this wholeheartedly.
And I learned some new things, thanks

The fact that you think "black slave" and "slave" are the same is crazy tbh

You know it's amazing how you can type on thing and how different people can interpret it I think that's the beauty in humanity. The diversity of creativity and thinking. Honestly, I'm kinda bored and annoyed with how much I have to explain my thought process in thinking. I even advocate for what I make my connections on on a misspelled, poorly grammered, not even coherent comment, but you know that's what I get for making a comment that nobody can properly comprehend. Cause i didn't type it right

Sorry I didn't finish that statement. So I was asking, why does it matter? If I talk about, let's use a metaphor, vanilla ice cream instead of Ice cream. This subgenre, of a bigger overlapping thing. Yeah. But I guess I just have to realize people are coming at this at a different point of view. I'm coming at this as somebody that went to an american lynching museum, slash slavery museum, and i saw a pair of shoes with a matching belt made from human skin. And you're probably coming from, this is somebody that didn't see that and didn't get traumatized.. i made a comment, poorly typed, about my frustrations of coming to a space to cope from my trauma, that I just digested. Just to Relive slash remember that trauma specifically when I saw that dog tied up scene that brought back me reading about one of the torture methods they used to do to black people. So I'm just coming at this at a different point of view from alot of you. Probably most of you. I think that's interesting. So I need to take a step back and realize people didn't see what I saw. So when I make my connections differently, I'd probably have to explain it so I don't want to and I don't think I need to, but I guess it's a "controversial" topic. Wish it wasn't.I wish it was a more open topic. Don't want to though to the fucking Comment to studpid webtoon, but you know, life is crazy

I'll be so real. I don't know how you were even able to comprehend my comment. But You think my poorly typed Commenting ability is gonna be able to clarify the time zone. I can't even clarify a punctuation mark. Also, yeah, I took it more as an attack on my intelligence. Because you thought I didn't know about all types of slavery because that's crazy work to not know that they're more than just black enslaved people, but I forget people are stupid. I just had to interact with stupid people in real life. So you came at a valid reason. Ngl.

Also the criminal part is very interesting. Cause I feel that modern slavery is just imprisoned people. This might be just my point of view as an American again because we have a high imprisonment rate. But yeah. Your Filipino that's crazy

The slavery of black africans was something unprecedented in history before. Yes, there was slavery. But not the type they invented for black africans. That was one of the cruelest slaveries ever. Before slaves had masters, yes. They were miserable and not free, yes. BUT they had rights. It was more like a social class. Black slaves were treated as if they were something beneath human and objects owned by white people. They did whatever they want with them. They made clothes out of their hair and shoes out of their skin.

is not an opinion, because it is true. That is something hitler did first. Then china is doing it now with Uyghurs and american with their prison inmates who OH WONDER WHO WOULD HAVE THOUGHT are mainly BIPOC. Who get prison sentences as long as possible for the same crime a white man just gets out on bail.

I understand your feelings and traumas. This topic is NOT an opinion, but a fact. However I dislike how you seemed to assume MY knowledge on the matter. "Somebody that didn't get traumatized", I did see horrible things and learned a lot about black slavery and how different it was from any other kind of slavery. I made a lot of research and also saw things as well. In no way or form am I going to disrespect anything you say, however I do think words hold a great and deep meaning. We shouldn't assume others' races, ethnicity, experiences or knowledge over one single comment. Which you did for many answers, and I think this is what made people angrier. This is just some communication tips, because nowadays people from different point of view come along.. we need to be careful.
We also shouldn't throw words around carelessly because of laziness, especially over a heavy topic like this one. I'm glad you realized this, and I'm really not blaming you for anything, this comment was more like an agreement on yours. Hope you have a good day!

Clock itttttt!