Probably because she only write a partial kids book and the rest just got filled in with whatever to make the fabric of reality come together. Everyone has a unique personality and past, so those details came from somewhere even though Eileen never specifically wrote them out. And don’t forget that Charney was the original MC whose details and surroundings were most fleshed out. There’s a lot of things that don’t add up about her existence.
How was she actually born? Magic shows Erno is her bio dad, but her mother died before she was born. Even if she just spontaneously poofed into existence, she’s still somehow associated with the Etam family via her supposed dad, so there are still a lot of unanswered questions.
I think its more than thzt her bio grandmother has a hate fir woman really profound ( she own a shop if the 1est client is a woman it'll close for the day cause it was bad luck), and i think all maternal figure were pushed away for her....
It’s possible that the trauma from that maternal figure tainted the very concept, but I’m not sure. After all, both of her parents are equally shitty to her, but she still ended up with a loving dad. Hopefully we’ll get an answer at some point
All i could think about was if shes the world creator why'd she make it so her moms dead if she controls the storyline