Responses
Unfortunately, you have an idea but your quite off on the what happened in her first life, why it all began for her second and how they dead in her third. But it is close for some of it to get revealed soon. Let's just say the crown prince is the root of most of it and her brother is a big piece of why. Not cuz he's evil but cuz he despises the crown prince and knows how evil he truly is.
Spoil meeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
All i can say is.. Ines is such a sucker for good looking men HAHAHAHAHAAHA like i can talk for myself lmao.
Anyway~ im just here to write things the way i understood them.. so for those that need it, read away.. for those that dont, scroll. HAHAHAHA
*Emil for Emiliano, coz im lazy*
So, Emil is saying Carcel is loved by God.. and thats because Carcel remembered the past like he dreamt them.. unlike Emil and Ines.. they remembered the past the moment they relived their lives.. while Carcel remembered them fairly recently.. by regaining bits and pieces of memories in certain times..
For Emil.. them remembering their past lives were punishments.. because they, Ines and him, ended their own lives.. which is a sin as per religion.. while Carcel probably lived his life to his death, thats why he was blessed.. by forgetting their tragic past.
The center of their fates, i think, is Ines.. the mysterious priest Ines saw was probably something like an angel, guiding people to their paths.. the best possible paths.. the happy ending.. and i THINK.. on Ines' and Carcel's first lives.. they were together.. and were happy but it was short lived because Ines died young.. like that flashback she recently had..
I THINK, on their first lives, Ines or Carcel prayed to have a rerun of their lives.. that way they could have btter choices or whatevs.. but since they died of natural causes.. they couldnt remember their past lives.. causing Ines to choose the crown prince on the 2nd run.. and ending her life tragicly because the prince was trash.. unlike what she'd expect.
On the 3rd run is when Ines met Emil and they went through all trials and tribulations.. only to off themselves because things got too hard.. ALL THESE TIMES.. on Ines' wiped unconsciousness.. the mysterious priest was there on all her lives.. probably trying to guide her back to her path with Carcel.. but wasnt successful.. due to choices people make ┑(￣Д ￣)┍ .. thats what i THINK that priest was trying to convey.. when him and Ines met on the street..
Ines thinks her live with Carcel now.. is her 3rd run.. when its actually the 4th.. and shes finally regaining her lost memories of her actual 1st life with Carcel where she died young.. that.. OR shes right that its her future life with Carcel.. where she dies young.. before him.. and Anastasio.. the priest.. was there for a prayer before her death.. but thats too cruel for an ending.. so i'd like to think its their past please~
Anyway~ i'm thinking the crown prince probably offed himself too when Ines offed herself when they were married.. because i can clearly see he's too inlove and obsessed with Ines.. even when Ines was broken and depressed.. so he probably couldnt live without her so i think he followed her to death.. and thats probably why he could remember their past lives.. because he's also being "punished". I think in this run.. its really gonna be the crown prince and his entourage thats gonna be the main antagonist..
What i also THINK btw.. is that they keep on looping because Ines or Carcel's prayer/wish on their 1st lives werent granted.. and i think Anastasio, that priest.. is there to grant it by guiding them in the background supposedly.. and as long as they dont be together.. they'd keep looping? Or as long as Ines keeps on offing herself.. the loop would continue because its a sin doing so? I think those 2 theories are quite close to the reason.. but i'd be excited to see something else of course! Thats the trill in reading~
What i really want to see.. hopefully.. is Ines and Carcel and Emil living happy lives.. and maybe seeing Ines have her baby again.. but with Carcel this time.. i really want the crown prince to have his shot at happiness too.. but i dont think that'd get fulfilled without Ines.. so i doubt.. but villains can be pitiful sometimes too.. i dont believe that someone can be born evil.. im pretty sure evil is made.
Anyway~ hopefully this helped someone out. Here's to hoping we get through all the angst this is gonna throw at us hahahahahahaha