Ines never chose carcel in their second life. She was betrothed to oscar and only ever liked him. But it was oscar's oen inferiority complex. He always suspected ines and carcel, maybe because he saw carcel's live for ines. And maybe ines and carcel's love was that great in the first timeline that he can't shake off the suspicion that they wouldn't fall in love again. But ines was always faithful to oscar. It was that dirty bastard's disgusting mentality.
Also, while the punishment for killing yourself was to remember their past memories, they also have a choice. God grants those who died without following their planned death a wish. So the 2nd timeline oscar wished to have his memories intact, the same with the 3rd timeline. Now he's in his fourth time. Can you imagine how obsessed he is with ines to want to keep all tge memories from his past 3 lives? Even the way he died..
his inferiority complex caused all of this misery.. fuck this guy
but i wrote ''she chose carcel before'' referencing the life(0) carcel and ines were married, not the one(1) where she got woth oscar. it's especially sad how he treated her because she was so devoted to him but he couldn't see that as he was still jealous of her marrying carcel in the previous timeline(0).
i thought the ''granting a whish'' was only for those who died without following their planned death because they were unfairly killed, and not for the ones who comitted suicide. i thought emilio could make a wish because he was unfairly killed. ines never seemed to have been granted a wish, so i thought those who commited suicide were not given a choice and just repeated their lifes with memories intact.
so oscar would've either killed himself and kept his memories, or died unfairly and wished to remember. but yeah it's scary his obsession had 4 lives to grow...
-Those who commit suicide do not get a wish.
-Carcel is remember due to Anastasio (God's apostle) interviening and giving him some memories back.
wait wait wait!!!!! so the timeline(1) where ines and oscar were married wasn't actually their first life?? oscar called ines ''your wife'' while talking to carcel, meaning they where actually married in the previous timeline(0), and nobody but oscar remembers. god grants oblivion to the souls that were unfairly taken from their destiny but lets those who committed suicide keep their memories... it means true destiny is for ines and carcel to be together!!! aaaah fated lovers T^T
so in their first life(0) they were together and somehow died unfairly. then oscar killed himself and decided to take revenge on carcel by marrying ines on the next timeline(1), but he was so resentful she chose carcel before that he mistreated her so bad she killed herself and started the next timeline(2).
carcel never had memories so he didn't kill himself at any point, but what about oscar.... he's too suspicious in the current timeline(3). he was so resentful and jealous in the timeline(1) ines and him were married, i can't believe he let go of her in this life(3). i think he commited suicide angain, actually remembers and choose another strategy to have her this time.
don't know why carcel's benn having flash of memories but i'm glad he knows what oscar did. can't wait for the confrontation
i think it's great he remembers cause ines will have the final confirmation she isn't crazy and alone in this timeloop. but idk if she'd want carcel to know of her dark and traumatizing past...