Women dont need to bleed for their first time. It can happen but it usually means that it was too rough or not done with true care. I get that it can be used for proof but that plot point was only brought up in the second life. In her first life where he was portrayed as cold and indifferent i doubt he acted with care like in the second. Thats my issue
Mostly true, but it also vastly depends on jone’s specific physiology. Hymens are very diferent in shape and nature, some so flexible they can survive multiple birth (!), some rigid enough to break from physical activities like horse riding… the pain or blood thing are also depending on that very strange vestigial piece of flesh.
But you’re still right ;

I need a lot more time to forgive him for that blood spot in the first timeline