Responses
I can take this obliviousness route since he's not the average garden variety supernatural creature like some vampire, fox spirit or even pantheon god or magical being... He's not only at the top of the food chain, but so far higher from anyone else, even Nia's just an ant to him...
Same here. Because she is screwed either way. So she might as well live in the doubt without really confirming what he is and just entertain him.
Wow, that's fucking insane and depressing. I want cosmic horror with toxicity and all, but the MC to be fully aware, knowledgeable, understands everything and chooses with their own free will. If she stops questioning and fighting back her own judgements, it will really be boring and sad.