What's with the purity culture?

ebby November 18, 2025 10:45 pm

Kinda just want to see people's takes on this.

There's a weird purity culture in BL fandoms, like... I've genuinely seen people say stuff like "I can handle incest/SA/abuse, but I draw the line at cheating." Like??? And half the time it's not even cheating, it's just them sleeping with someone else while being aware the other character exists. Almost any time there's a character that sleeps around (when they're not in a committed relationship), there's a significant amount of slut shaming in response, and I don't get it.

But even when it is cheating, how is it that that is treated so much worse than actual sexual assault?

Responses
    Oldest account November 18, 2025 11:09 pm

    I draw the line at SA or abuse , I genuinely stop enjoying it for me a dark romance have to be with boundaries he can be manipulative to certain extent but no SA.
    As for the cheating thing I think its more have to do witht the story like the MC and ml are fo each other we can't see them with anyone else and this mindset is for people who like 2D stories without much of depth
    Ngl one thing I dislike about any Asian story is that the main couple have to be each other first if not they to should be meeting As kid once or twice like its fate they r with each other

    Crispy_Robin November 18, 2025 11:45 pm

    I used to be one of those(someone who was find with SA and r*pe but not with cheating)....now I can't tolerate any....still can't digest cheating(something I am never gonna be okay with.....but I hate it when it is proper cheating.....as in they were in a relationship and the other party cheated)....but now I genuinely hate SA and r*pe....as days are going on I am also getting annoyed with borderline r*pe(as in the characters are in a relationship but then one of them is being forceful and so the other reluctantly agree....)

    Crispy_Robin November 18, 2025 11:49 pm
    I draw the line at SA or abuse , I genuinely stop enjoying it for me a dark romance have to be with boundaries he can be manipulative to certain extent but no SA.As for the cheating thing I think its more have... Oldest account

    I used to freaking love the meeting as a child part....but bcz it's sooo freaking over done, that everytime I see it(if it is without any reason)...I just feel like my eyes rolling

    Oldest account November 19, 2025 12:02 am
    I used to freaking love the meeting as a child part....but bcz it's sooo freaking over done, that everytime I see it(if it is without any reason)...I just feel like my eyes rolling Crispy_Robin

    Wow same it gave the story something cute and with destiny vibe but now it's just annoying

    dokjacoat November 19, 2025 1:10 am
    I used to be one of those(someone who was find with SA and r*pe but not with cheating)....now I can't tolerate any....still can't digest cheating(something I am never gonna be okay with.....but I hate it when i... Crispy_Robin

    Agree, unfortunately lots of manhwa have it now (not all, obviously)

    Me_for_ president November 19, 2025 2:43 am

    To answer your last question the main reason why so many people not just BL readers, think or treat cheating is worse than rape is because they view rape as a confirmation of desire and obsessing over a person to the point where they can’t control themselves (which is not true) while cheating means that they found someone else attractive, and desirable other than you.

    ebby November 19, 2025 8:21 am
    To answer your last question the main reason why so many people not just BL readers, think or treat cheating is worse than rape is because they view rape as a confirmation of desire and obsessing over a person ... Me_for_ president

    OKAY yes, I honestly was thinking something like this as well, but I wasn't sure how to articulate it and I think you did it perfectly.

    ebby November 19, 2025 8:37 am
    I used to be one of those(someone who was find with SA and r*pe but not with cheating)....now I can't tolerate any....still can't digest cheating(something I am never gonna be okay with.....but I hate it when i... Crispy_Robin

    Yeah, I absolutely hate cheating. I think it breaks the relationship if it is genuine cheating (that is not coerced/misconstrued), because disloyalty to that degree is just not forgivable to me. To disrespect your partner by being with someone else behind their back is betrayal, pure and simple, and it ruins any romance story for me.
    That being said, I just think that rape is SO much worse, because it not only disregards the person's feelings, it shows that the assaulter's desire is more important to them than the comfort and safety of the other person. It's a complete omission of a fundamental respect for another person's agency.
    And I agree, I hate any sort of non-con/dub-con, and hate that I have to turn a blind eye to it so frequently to read otherwise really good stories. Coercion and force aren't romantic. I wish authors would stop pretending it is.

    Crispy_Robin November 19, 2025 8:56 pm
    Wow same it gave the story something cute and with destiny vibe but now it's just annoying Oldest account

    Yh true.....I still love destined relationship tho(as in if it was stated from the very start or the destiny just fcking make sense....that's like one of my fav trope)....but adding that they met each other as a child just for the sake of it(with no reason whatsoever) is annoying....

    Crispy_Robin November 19, 2025 9:02 pm
    Yeah, I absolutely hate cheating. I think it breaks the relationship if it is genuine cheating (that is not coerced/misconstrued), because disloyalty to that degree is just not forgivable to me. To disrespect y... ebby

    Honestly both ruins the story for me....altho ngl there might be a chance of me giving the story a chance even tho r*pe is involved if two things r a part of it(one is proper acknowledgement and the other is proper redemption arc)....altho it will still be in the back of my mind as I will be reading it....the same kinda goes for cheating except I haven't come across any like that.....also agree with the last sentence