A guess

Stress1234 November 14, 2020 5:51 pm

I think the one who saved Josh Garland/Marlene during the fight with werewolves back then was the leader, Kieffer. That's why he meet Josh directly at chapter 8 when he could easily sent someone else. He and Josh wanted the war between Garland and werewolves to end, but Kieffer is still being cautious because things might go awry and cause a bloodshed.
And that bloodshed is about to happen. The idea of sending a picture of Josh as a hostage to Garland is a very bad idea. It could only make them launch an attack to save Josh. They should've shot a video message of him being happy among them and said that werewolves are not bad as the Garland persumed. Or they shouldn't send anything at all.

Responses
    KathE November 15, 2020 1:28 am

    The situation is not as simple as the Galland family not liking werewolves. There are two major reasons the Gallands are hunting them down, the first is to make money. They aren’t Van Helsing, who is typically viewing the occupation of monster hunting as protection of the innocent, the Gallands hunt werewolves, kill them, and then sell the wolves various body parts to people who see werewolves as cures to different ailments (see chapter 1). They are the mafia and this is a main source of income (see the beginning of ch 4-5). The second reason, and the one I believe you are thinking about, is the head of the family’s obsession for revenge for the death of his son and daughter-in-law, Joshua’s parents (also in ch. 4-5). However I think this is either a convenient excuse the head is using or he is just actually insane. Because as we learned in ch. 12 that the wolves responsible for Joshua’s parents death are already dead. But no matter what I think Joshua’s grandfather (the head) has always hated werewolves, I think he proved this theory by murdering Kiefer’s wife and children (ch. 8).

    KathE November 15, 2020 1:30 am

    I think the “werewolves are not as bad as you think” could work on someone like Allen and maybe even Randolph (the head advisor to the Gallands) but not to Joshua’s grandfather, who is calling the shots here.

    Stress1234 November 15, 2020 5:01 am
    The situation is not as simple as the Galland family not liking werewolves. There are two major reasons the Gallands are hunting them down, the first is to make money. They aren’t Van Helsing, who is typicall... KathE

    Oh I didn't know there is money value from it. I didn't pay attention. I thought it was pure revenge or hatred sparks by fear.

    Stress1234 November 15, 2020 5:02 am
    I think the “werewolves are not as bad as you think” could work on someone like Allen and maybe even Randolph (the head advisor to the Gallands) but not to Joshua’s grandfather, who is calling the shots h... KathE

    You're right. It's useless to explain thing to someone who is blinded by hatred.

    KathE November 15, 2020 9:24 am
    Oh I didn't know there is money value from it. I didn't pay attention. I thought it was pure revenge or hatred sparks by fear. Stress1234

    That is totally understandable. Honestly, I have re-read this story around 15 times and I just realized that there more there than hatred or fear with my last re-read.

    KathE November 15, 2020 9:26 am
    You're right. It's useless to explain thing to someone who is blinded by hatred. Stress1234

    Exactly! I can’t wait for this dang grandfather to die so Marlene and Lili can live happy peaceful lives.

    .....Or at least that is what I hope happens.