I dont understand, so in the first life carcel and ines were married? Where did you get that from? Did i miss anything on this chapter or is that a spoiler?
The above are all memories Carcel just remembered from the timeline when Ines married Oscar. The implication is, Ines and Carcel were married in the timeline before Ines married Oscar.
On the most recent ch, page 69, Oscar said to Carcel:“Did you really think I would love your wife when she’s spread her legs for a bastard like you?”https://www.mangago.me/read-manga/the_broken_ring_this_... StoryofMinglan
So she first married carcel before Oscar, then she married in the next life, marries emiliano, then carcel again, and all this is prolly because Oscar committed the original sin and is the reason ines keeps coming back??????
So she first married carcel before Oscar, then she married in the next life, marries emiliano, then carcel again, and all this is prolly because Oscar committed the original sin and is the reason ines keeps com... this better
Her first husband is Carcel. They died unfated deaths so they were given a second chance to live to correct their fate.
Partly due to Ines’s wishes and partly due to Oscar’s wishes, Ines fell into Oscar’s hands in the timeline that was Ines’s second chance. She then committed suicide and regressed to the third timeline where she ran away with Emiliano. Then she committed suicide and regressed to the fourth timeline where she chose Carcel at 6 years old.
Hence the name The Broken Ring.
Oscar is not the one who originally ruined Carcel and Ines’s lives in the first timeline. It might surprise many to know that Oscar was busy with his wife and mistresses in the first life. After Ines and Carcel married, Oscar barely saw them. They lived in Esposa and Calztela while Oscar lived in Mendoza.
Her first husband is Carcel. They died unfated deaths so they were given a second chance to live to correct their fate. Partly due to Ines’s wishes and partly due to Oscar’s wishes, Ines fell into Oscar’s... StoryofMinglan
thank u for this! after having read this manhwa since chapter 1 was released and still having a hard time to understand everything til now, this comment was what gave me clarity!!!
my question is what was ines’ wish after she died from her first life?
and if Oscar didn’t really mind Ines and Carcel in the first life, why the heck did he up and decide to marry Ines in the second life? Because of his insecurities against Carcel?
thank u for this! after having read this manhwa since chapter 1 was released and still having a hard time to understand everything til now, this comment was what gave me clarity!!! my question is what was ines... g-ann
Ines wish after the first life partly influenced her tragedies:
Since she was an extremely difficult wife to Carcel for a number of reasons, after she died an unfated death, she told the Apostle the following wishes:
1. Let Carcel live a life that has nothing to do with her 2. Let Carcel find a better wife than her 3. Let Carcel have healthy children 4. Let Carcel never die again from the crown prince 5. Let Carcel be able to travel to beautiful places with his wife and family
The Apostle hinted to her that only Carcel will benefit from her wishes. He asked Ines if she’s willing to bear the consequences. Ines said she’s willing and well, we knew how that turned out. She ended up being unable to bear the consequences so she committed suicide. I think the apostle already foresaw her tragedies because he tried to get Carcel to overrule Ines’s wishes but Carcel decided to respect Ines’s wishes.
Oscar always wanted Ines since she’s the highest ranking girl but he wasn’t obsessed with her. He used to harass all the noble girls. It’s after he premeditatedly married her in the second timeline that he became obsessed with her. Moreover, since Valeztenas deposed the him as crown prince in the first true timeline, Oscar was hellbent on revenge against them. That’s one of the reasons why he chose Ines besides the fact that since he had memories, he knew exactly how to win her over and gain the advantage over Carcel. In the first timeline Ines knew early on Oscar was a pervert. He used to lift up the dresses of little girls including herself. She knew to steer clear of him. She knew since a little girl that Carcel was by far better than Oscar.
I dont understand, so in the first life carcel and ines were married? Where did you get that from? Did i miss anything on this chapter or is that a spoiler?
On the most recent ch, page 69, Oscar said to Carcel:
“Did you really think I would love your wife when she’s spread her legs for a bastard like you?”
https://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/the_broken_ring_this_marriage_will_fail_anyway/uu/br_chapter-286127/pg-69/
On page 72, Oscar tells Carcel:
“It’s sad you still don’t have your memories back…that you two still can’t remember each other”.
https://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/the_broken_ring_this_marriage_will_fail_anyway/uu/br_chapter-286127/pg-72/
The above are all memories Carcel just remembered from the timeline when Ines married Oscar. The implication is, Ines and Carcel were married in the timeline before Ines married Oscar.
So she first married carcel before Oscar, then she married in the next life, marries emiliano, then carcel again, and all this is prolly because Oscar committed the original sin and is the reason ines keeps coming back??????
Her first husband is Carcel. They died unfated deaths so they were given a second chance to live to correct their fate.
Partly due to Ines’s wishes and partly due to Oscar’s wishes, Ines fell into Oscar’s hands in the timeline that was Ines’s second chance. She then committed suicide and regressed to the third timeline where she ran away with Emiliano. Then she committed suicide and regressed to the fourth timeline where she chose Carcel at 6 years old.
Hence the name The Broken Ring.
Oscar is not the one who originally ruined Carcel and Ines’s lives in the first timeline. It might surprise many to know that Oscar was busy with his wife and mistresses in the first life. After Ines and Carcel married, Oscar barely saw them. They lived in Esposa and Calztela while Oscar lived in Mendoza.
thank u for this! after having read this manhwa since chapter 1 was released and still having a hard time to understand everything til now, this comment was what gave me clarity!!!
my question is what was ines’ wish after she died from her first life?
and if Oscar didn’t really mind Ines and Carcel in the first life, why the heck did he up and decide to marry Ines in the second life? Because of his insecurities against Carcel?
Ines wish after the first life partly influenced her tragedies:
Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer
Since she was an extremely difficult wife to Carcel for a number of reasons, after she died an unfated death, she told the Apostle the following wishes:
1. Let Carcel live a life that has nothing to do with her
2. Let Carcel find a better wife than her
3. Let Carcel have healthy children
4. Let Carcel never die again from the crown prince
5. Let Carcel be able to travel to beautiful places with his wife and family
The Apostle hinted to her that only Carcel will benefit from her wishes. He asked Ines if she’s willing to bear the consequences. Ines said she’s willing and well, we knew how that turned out. She ended up being unable to bear the consequences so she committed suicide. I think the apostle already foresaw her tragedies because he tried to get Carcel to overrule Ines’s wishes but Carcel decided to respect Ines’s wishes.
Oscar always wanted Ines since she’s the highest ranking girl but he wasn’t obsessed with her. He used to harass all the noble girls. It’s after he premeditatedly married her in the second timeline that he became obsessed with her. Moreover, since Valeztenas deposed the him as crown prince in the first true timeline, Oscar was hellbent on revenge against them. That’s one of the reasons why he chose Ines besides the fact that since he had memories, he knew exactly how to win her over and gain the advantage over Carcel. In the first timeline Ines knew early on Oscar was a pervert. He used to lift up the dresses of little girls including herself. She knew to steer clear of him. She knew since a little girl that Carcel was by far better than Oscar.
thank you for this