Charly want to read (All 493)

Charly is reading (All 151)

Charly already read (All 115)

Charly's Album ( All 0 )

Charly's List ( All 1 )

Title Update Recommend
Yaoi Reads(1) 2017-04-11 0

Charly's topics ( All 85 )

Charly August 30, 2025 5:37 pm

This story is going right in the “could have been a good four stars” category. I don’t even know where to begin; the art is literally the only reason majority of us are still here any way because the plot has gone completely down the gutter.

Beom could have been a great seme but he’s just as insensitive as deokchil. Sure, we know he likes Hui-Jae but he’s never even properly apologized for doing what he did in the first season. Neither does he completely take responsibility for the fact that he caused Hui-Jae’s trauma (after finding out everything).

In the end he tells Hui-Jae his real name and…that’s it??? There’s too much pointless smut in this story and I’m not vibing with it anymore.

What a waste.

    melunhae August 30, 2025 6:32 pm

    true, the art is the only thing why i keep reading this, but the plot is just going nowhere, not in the slightest. I wish we would get some progress somewhere... truly a waste

    Tokutaru August 30, 2025 7:46 pm

    Yeah, the story is what it is. I thought things were getting interesting when they added The red hair guy to the mix, But now that the series is over. Would the love triangle keep the series going? I don't think so. It was a fun read But it was time to end.

    Charly August 30, 2025 8:41 pm
    true, the art is the only thing why i keep reading this, but the plot is just going nowhere, not in the slightest. I wish we would get some progress somewhere... truly a waste melunhae

    I don’t think we’ll ever get anything. I saw the last few chapters and if you don’t mind spoilers, Beom disappears AGAIN after he finds out about Hui-Jae’s issue and when Hui-Jae goes back to the island, Beom reappears after a month. They don’t even have a proper conversation and Beom’s taking him again and they have sex, which is when Beom whispers his real name to Hui-Jae. He asks him if the whole “I’ll take care of you” is still on the table and I suppose that’s enough to make Hui-Jae forgive him??


    I won’t criticize Hui-Jae too much because he’s young, naive and this is his first relationship. But Beom definitely took advantage of that.

    Charly August 30, 2025 8:43 pm
    Yeah, the story is what it is. I thought things were getting interesting when they added The red hair guy to the mix, But now that the series is over. Would the love triangle keep the series going? I don't thin... Tokutaru

    I thought so too, but unfortunately nothing really came of it. Both love interests are shitty men, lol. Hui-Jae deserves so much better.

    melunhae August 30, 2025 8:43 pm
    I don’t think we’ll ever get anything. I saw the last few chapters and if you don’t mind spoilers, Beom disappears AGAIN after he finds out about Hui-Jae’s issue and when Hui-Jae goes back to the island... Charly

    thanks for the spoilers, i dont mind at all.
    means i wont be reading this until like 20 more chapters or something when its done

    Bella Rose August 31, 2025 12:48 am
    thanks for the spoilers, i dont mind at all.means i wont be reading this until like 20 more chapters or something when its done melunhae

    We only have 6 more chapters until season 2 is complete according to Manga Updates.

    melunhae August 31, 2025 10:14 am
    We only have 6 more chapters until season 2 is complete according to Manga Updates. Bella Rose

    ohh so that mean season one will basically be nothing, so we'll have to wait for season two

    Charly August 31, 2025 11:30 am
    ohh so that mean season one will basically be nothing, so we'll have to wait for season two melunhae

    We’re in season 2 rn

Charly July 24, 2025 1:13 pm

So for those who are curious, I’d recommend reading the novel if you don’t mind Mukyeom being trash for the beginning chapters. The story is actually pretty good, Mukyeom is very stubborn about acknowledging his feelings though they spill out in obvious ways like him getting possessive/jealous.

However, the yearning/chase arc is EXCELLENT. Hajoon is no pushover and Mukyeom had to seriously WORK to get back into his good graces. At one point I thought it’d end with them just reconciling their differences and moving on. But the reconciliation was well done. Mukyeom learns how to be accountable for his actions and is actually quite sweet.

The novel is on Novel Updates.

    Zeruuuuu July 25, 2025 6:01 pm

    i dont wanna read the spoiler but im interested in the novel. is it well-written?

    Charly July 25, 2025 6:04 pm
    i dont wanna read the spoiler but im interested in the novel. is it well-written? Zeruuuuu

    It is actually, I was impressed. However, there are parts where the perspective switches to first-person so it can be a bit jarring to figure out whose POV it is.

    Bejdjjeje July 25, 2025 10:49 pm

    Do you have a link to the novel?

    Charly July 25, 2025 10:54 pm
    Do you have a link to the novel? Bejdjjeje

    https://www.novelupdates.com/series/halfline/

Charly's questions ( All 1 )

Charly February 3, 2018 3:16 am

Hello, I'm searching for a manga title about an uke who always tries to strangle a seme every time they slept together (it was something he always did in his sleep). The seme found out about the uke's past romance with a man who he found out died and had wanted to be with the uke.

There was also a particular kind of flower the deceased seme always sent to the uke...

Charly's favorite ( All 4 )

Your Favourite Youtuber 08-30 17:38
Long Rant about Adult choices. 01-09 00:10
Real Season 2 Spoilers 08-30 23:50
That translator note 08-26 17:38

Charly's message board ( All 0 )

> 5 people followed Charly