
Do you guys think that the vision of her death that she was shown was the past or the future? The one where she’s on her deathbed with Adronda by her side… where Cárcel was nowhere to be found…There’s no way this has a sad ending… like NO PLEASE!! I will literally END IT ALL FUUUUUU

Yes. There are already clues that it is a past life. In ep96, at the beginning of the episode, Ines has a dream while she’s dying and she sees a memory of her teenage self and teenage Cárcel at a lake in Esposa. In this current timeline, Ines and Carcel never courted especially when they were teenagers so it cannot be a vision from this current timeline. Fortunately, the next episode that will be released this Saturday will confirm it’s a past life. The Korean episodes are ahead of the English episodes.
Ep 96: Teenage Carcel and Ines
https://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/the_broken_ring_this_marriage_will_fail_anyway/uu/br_chapter-252476/pg-20/

You will get the answer why. We already saw she was dying. She was only 28 years old when she died. So this season we will get some answers about why she died so young. The story has a HE.
The reason why she lived again several times was answered in Bilboa. When a person die an unfated death they get a second chance to live again. She received a second chance to live so that she could meet her true death. However, because she has committed suicide twice, she has not yet met her true death. That’s why her fervent wish in this current life is to meet her true death.

Can someone just tell me what your theories are regarding the beginning and end of chapter 13? Everybody’s talking about how this is inappropriate blah blah blah and it’s not. He’s literally an adult. But anyway, I need someone to talk about what’s going on because I’m a little lost. What are y’all theories?

I say he has artificial memories and he was a failed experiment that they decided to keep using for the purpose of the research since they ppl funding this whole thing aim to make their experiments smart. The MC got hurt and they just wiped his memories since he supposedly wasn’t that involved with the ML but they still assigned him to MC. Now that dream is all weird it implies that we can’t trust the MC because his memories aren’t intact he’s now an unreliable narrator for this story I say the ppl built him an entire life. But the ML keeps maybe being reborn or having this memories put into the same body wi the the intention of forgetting and he keeps remembering. I think I’m thinking too deep though

No, I think you're right, you're almost there. I was actually thinking the same thing, but that AP0 and AP1 were different like twins. Judging by the last chapter tho, I think he's also the same person. And there's definitely some history of accident which is also why he's the one chosen to be his caretaker.
What do you all think about her brother? He’s such a multifaceted character. He’s not all bad but he’s not all good if we consider his actions in her 2nd life. I don’t know how to feel about him, I just know I can’t hate him ugh. Feelings are so complicated.
Who? After so long I can't even remember the brother
Inés’s brother who killed her fiancée, Emiliano.
There is no character in this story that is all good. As Ines said in ep82, she loves her brother even though she tried not to love nor hate him.
I remembered from the novel that luciano had always been prioritizing ines above all else, crown prince had been threatening him from time to time (that includes telling him that he will SA ines if luciano doesn't follow him) that's why he was forced to kill emilliano bcuz the shitty crown prince told him to
Emiliano was never her fiancé. Oscar, the crown prince was her fiancé. Emiliano even said it in the last chapter he appeared in. He said that his life was peaceful now because he was no longer the painter who would paint Ines and she was no longer the crown prince’s fiancée. A big reason why that timeline turned out tragically in the first place is because Ines was the crown prince’s fiancé and by running away with another man, the entire country condemned her. No one knew she had regressed so no one understood why she would run anway after being in a romantic relationship with the crown prince for 10 years.
As to Luciano, Ines reasoned that Luciano was under a lot of pressure from the imperial family because she ran away leaving her family is deep trouble. She believes Luciano made a cold decision to kill the man she ran away with because of the circumstances. That’s why she blames herself for the tragedy and not her brother.