Cleopatra November 13, 2025 6:29 pm

Just re-read and realized that the task he gave her is the same mentality as what Shiguma did when he gave her Jugemu. As in she had to figure out the meaning herself because otherwise she wouldn't own it. Guess they cant avoid being alike

Cleopatra November 10, 2025 9:21 pm

In my headcanon Lilian is bi and was also in love with Athy's mom and idgaf

Cleopatra November 9, 2025 2:28 pm

I have maybe a random take but I think I would have liked it better if her life with the prince was her first one all along, and she just chose differently with Escalante, instead of him being "the first and right one all along", but maybe that's also because I never liked the trope of lovers that had secretly already met when younger/as children and made a promise or something along those lines to signal fate. It always felt a lot more artificial to me than watching people stumbling through their choices, a lot less about characters' agencies, like everyone is some sort of passive recipient of their destiny. Though I do think it's going to be a lot more nuanced than that as well and this story plays a lot with "destiny" as a concept as well.

I feel like the meaning of these past memories are that they were both much younger and immature in their first lives as lovers, as well as people who symbolized so much power, and hurt each other, but now they are able to communicate properly and learn from their previous mistakes. That would be super interesting also, but we'll see!

    Souma November 9, 2025 2:38 pm

    Spoiler


    From what i gathered from some comments in the first life she told him something that turned into a curse wich is why they are repeating their lives

    StoryofMinglan November 9, 2025 3:02 pm

    This story is so complexed and nuanced that it’s not only about destiny which applies to all characters in this story much like it applies to everyone in real life according to Christianity which is the basis of this story. While Ines and Carcel -just like every character in this story- has their destiny, they still live their lives by their own choices. There is indeed an overarching theme that is similar to Christian theology of foreknowledge and predestination (even just saw the latter in Anne Shirley anime), the author writes the story in such a way that the characters still have their agency or free will. The author also has a knack of subverting cliches and I like that.

    I do agree that ONE of the purposes of the 1st TL memories is to help Ines grow and develop but there is so much more to the original life. It is the origin of Ines’s tragedies. Frankly, I find it abundantly much more compelling than starting her original life at Oscar. I would encourage readers to wait to see how it all unfolds because Oscar’s motive started from there and Oscar wasn’t even obsessed with Ines in the first TRUE life like readers seem to think. The story has more revelations ahead before the end.

    OyaOyaOya November 9, 2025 3:14 pm

    SPOILER







    she wasn't supposed to choose the prince at all from what i read from the spoilers. The prince also have his memories that's why he deliberately planned to make ines his on the 2nd timeline. tbh if the prince wasn't such an a--hole these wouldn't happen. Even on the 1st timeline the prince had a part that led carcel to his death.

    you can say that there's a destiny play but I would say it's more like the "god" was giving them chances to make things right by "cursing them" (?) aka their memories intact and redoing their life again and again

    Bea November 9, 2025 10:23 pm

    Nah the fact that Oscar wasn’t her first marriage healed something in me I was very happy

    Cleopatra November 10, 2025 10:37 am

    y'all I dont want to read spoilers but thanks!

    Cleopatra November 10, 2025 2:26 pm
    This story is so complexed and nuanced that it’s not only about destiny which applies to all characters in this story much like it applies to everyone in real life according to Christianity which is the basis... StoryofMinglan

    Yeah I agree that they pull it off with a lot of nuance and there's a lot of trope subversion, ! Sorry maybe I should have said I initially was a bit reluctant about that reveal but I am more intrigued now.

Cleopatra September 20, 2025 4:55 pm

what a whirlwind of emotions in this scene lol first horny and low key a refreshing smut scene, then sad and depressing then awkward and funny omg I feel like I went through it all

Cleopatra August 13, 2025 8:29 pm

I love this sort of minimal and clean but pleasing to the eye art. Like with precise lines. Also tbh with Korean webtoons so popular these days full of chaebols and the like it's so refreshing to read about normal type of people going through small but significant problems! It feels like even when the story is not fantasy or sci fi what's trending is only out of touch shit where for a ml to be attractive he needs to be packing not only down there but also in his wallet.

Really miss when stories like this were more prominent!

Cleopatra August 13, 2025 6:44 pm

I am honestly very impressed with this webtoon. It depicts their toxic (and imo sometimes abusive) relationship very well and really explores how these relationships happen, despite the fact that ofc irl we would not be privy to a situation like that.

Like Bjorn is a well written character and the author does not excuse or justifies his actions, though they explain them well. He's a cynical man, good looking, healthy, and literally one of THE most powerful people in their world, who therefore naturally thinks of himself subconsciously as apart (and often superior) to everyone else, and who also understands that he himself is a symbol of many things and not just an individual who therefore HAS to put certain duties above his own desires, and has in that way distanced himself from how he feels and what he really wants. That kind of mix of arrogance, dissociation and absolute privilege, and the way he perceives Erna as the one person he gets to project those impulses he is not allowed to have in front of others onto, who will accept him no matter what, is a cocktail that, when faced with criticism or his own shortcomings when it comes to her, turns mean, cold, and abusive. Because he is an abuser, at bare minimum verbally, and their dynamic is completely rotten.

Also, the depiction of power imbalance is done honestly frustratingly well. They have a small age difference, and Erna is a far less world experienced and in some ways sheltered person, which makes that difference feel stronger, but their gap in status is miles bigger. When people hear about things like grooming or abuse of power, they think it means someone's boss is a moustache twirling villain that sadistically violates people beneath them, but the truth of it is abusing one's power comes naturally to someone when they, because of the fact that they are blind to their privileges and the fact that there's no one above them to tell them off, will assert their will on someone beneath them as if they are equals, not understanding that a) the other person would be intimidated at the prospect of saying "no" to them, b) that the other person would prioritize the abuser's version of reality/events over their own, and that c) there is an underlying way in which power imbalances affect the way you even fully understand someone beneath as fully a subject the way you understand yourself.

All three of these things are true in Bjorn and Erna's relationship. He is calm and collected usually, yet reacts immaturely and meanly to her expressing hurt or dissatisfaction towards him, is blind to the fact that he is assuming he gets to do that and that she does not, loves her yet objectifies her and looks down on her, and in turn, Erna tiptoes on eggshells around his moods and whims, never speaks to him as harshly as he does, and sees herself as an object around him, focusing on how she can be "useful" to him, as "a pretty wife" or a "shield" or a fucking womb, and equates herself to objects (which he does too tbh) like a trophy or a fake flower. Even when he is doing something out of worry or care towards her, he never actually takes her position and what she herself SAYS she needs seriously. He always prioritizes his own perspective on things, assuming that she doesn't know what she wants herself, literally treating her as an inferior species of human many times.

It's kind of chilling to see how the story doesn't pull any punches about it the way usual stories do about "toxic ml"s or whatnot where they go "but he's huuuuuwt and he's been tormenteeeed and he has lots of responsibilities!!! Don't you feel soooowwwwy for himmm?" In this case, Bjorn's not abusive in the black and white way idk a typical villain would be, but honestly he's not just mean in a kind'a downplayed tsundere way either. He's a literally privileged a f asshole who is repressed and distant as hell from all people around him by his upbringing, cynical as hell from his first marriage and prone to throwing tantrums in front of the only person that threatens the way he perceives himself and who could make him feel vulnerable. And idk honestly, I'm kind of amazed at that, and I have no idea what kind of rehab his character could go on to convince us that he could be redeemed, but I'm very very curious.

Also I love Erna as a character, I know some people find her too passive, but that's kind of the point. She couldn't be any other way, the whole world was calling her worthless, just a pretty face, not good enough and so on, and probably to some extent of the universe her husband inhabits and the traits expected of someone in her position, that is true, but it's not her fault in any way and not even something she could ever control. What a grueling reality to live with. This marriage robbed her of her innocence and her vitality, and she probably won't be the same anymore, yet instead of letting it turn her into a shell of herself completely, she decided it was enough and to move on. I lowkey love her.

Idk I really like this story and was blown away with the nuances it has compared to what's expected of stories like these these days

    Cleopatra August 13, 2025 6:54 pm

    btw Gladys is also a great character, like people call her evil and a witch or whatnot, but she's basically a sheltered and privileged a f princess who was not used to being told no and thought she could have it all because she has always been told that she is special and she deserves everything. Like I think they say she was 17 or something around that time when she was married to Bjorn, a hormonal entitles teenager with that much entitlement doesn't need to be evil to do what she did.

    And her entitlement in trying to get back with Bjorn yet as he says not even do anything out of malice or by being calculated, just by naturally assuming that she'd get away with everything because why wouldn't she? *chef's kiss* And I love how ppl go from calling her an angel and a perfect woman to calling her a witch or master manipulator or whatever. Honestly classic misogynist madonna/whore complex shit tho I'm not sure how much the author has also internalized but it works perfectly well so who cares tbh.

    Sorry for the walltext to the one person who might read this, I just like this story and was rereading and needed somewhere to put my thoughts at.

    sweetie August 17, 2025 4:05 am

    Plz i love your thoughts on this. That’s a major reason why i enjoy this story so much (even tho i usually stay away from a lot of angst) it’s just so real. It really shows how it is to be in that type of unstable relationship, especially one where you’re just left constantly wanting and hoping that the other will show and say more as to how they feel about you. The whole build up of everything is just so painfully beautiful. Even her getting to the point where she’s done, how she suddenly felt awake and she could see clearly now. It’s just all so real and relatable in so many ways, the portrayal of grief is so well done in this story

    also sorry for my long rant I just finished it and it was so good I had to say smth too

    he tian's cock is my world August 25, 2025 6:10 am

    i loveeee this input (▰˘◡˘▰)

Cleopatra August 11, 2025 10:52 pm

ohmygooooooooooood guys I read chapter 61 I'm about to die THAT FUCKER LISTER OMFG I LEGIT TEARED UP THIS PIECE OF SHIIIIIIIT

    Aoikis August 12, 2025 10:06 am

    Raw link pls ╥﹏╥

    Cleopatra August 12, 2025 11:44 am
    Raw link pls ╥﹏╥ Aoikis

    it's not raw it's at templetoons they do old school translation. I could not wait when I saw they were ahead

    Aoikis August 12, 2025 12:56 pm
    it's not raw it's at templetoons they do old school translation. I could not wait when I saw they were ahead Cleopatra

    I see, thanks for answering ლ(´ڡ`ლ)

    toaster strudel August 12, 2025 8:49 pm

    pls tell me he didnt rape sylhan

    Cleopatra August 13, 2025 3:30 am
    pls tell me he didnt rape sylhan toaster strudel

    no, at least not yet. Just go read honestly I was legit fuming... >___> aaaaarghhh

    Hell August 17, 2025 11:38 am
    pls tell me he didnt rape sylhan toaster strudel

    ...
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    He did, in the novel as far as I remember

    tytyrose August 29, 2025 5:19 pm
    ..............He did, in the novel as far as I remember Hell

    was it like once or multiple times ?

Cleopatra August 11, 2025 10:21 pm

shit the plot thickens! I have to say it's refreshing to read a yaoi with actual good plot like this. Also I love that just like how we have been disoriented from the beginning, Sylhan is starting to detangle a lot of threads we have been confused by so it feels very cathartic. Go Sylhan!

Cleopatra July 30, 2025 6:33 pm

I see lesbian i click. Before I proceed, any opinions from readers, is it worth it?

    Alien July 30, 2025 9:16 pm

    It's good. Just... Just prepare your heart comrade

    Alien July 30, 2025 9:17 pm

    Oh there's quite some time skip here and there but I don't necessarily mind it cuz it's telling the story anyway and it's not confusing. Just feels a bit rushed but that's about it.

Cleopatra July 16, 2025 6:51 pm

If you want to read a realistic narrative about bullying I think 3gatsu no Lion has a really good arc on middle school bullying though it's quite far into the story

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.