Honestly I get both Andrew and Luke’s pov, Andrew’s more skeptical and Luke’s more optimistic about people. Imo Luke’s not naive, he’s just trusting with the people he knows. Andrew knows a bit more when it comes to Bruno and his motives though, so I’ll give him that. I just really hope they can smooth things out!!
I feel like Andrew and Luke are just really different when it comes to what makes them happy or what gives them contentment. Luke values friendship and exploring relationships while Andrew is really selective and now zeroed in on one person which is Luke. What Luke thinks would make Andrew happy doesn't necessarily apply to him, same with Luke. I don’t think either of them mean to hurt each other but when their values clash this hard it’s easier said than done, I hope they can find a middle ground somehow. On another note Luke’s understanding towards Bruno was refreshing to see, I think he can sense that Bruno’s circumstances are pushing him to go against his conscience