be overrated or underrated?

Would yall rather be called overrated or be called underrated?

Overrated like there are a fair amount of people saying you don't deserve the hype, that you weren't even that good, and constantly lowering your worth, BUT you're still famous, well-known, and a lot of people still love and support you.

Or

Underrated like you're not much appreciated, only a small amount of people pay attention to you, you don't get that much credit for your work, BUT that small amount of people shower you with praises and tells you that you deserve all the hype in the world.

I'm curious as to what most of yall would choose :)