do you think One Direction would have been as much famous if they were to debut now

One Direction is literally the best. Enjoying them is about the vibes not the technically quality or skill. One day you'll get it trust me. Anyways probably not. Mainly because they were so ridiculously famous so they could do really well and still be nowhere near what they had at their peak. But also because they'd probably end up competing pretty......   reply

i don't think so. one direction was a product of its time imo. the early 2010s still had something which is largely absent today, which are western tween & teen idols. tween/teen idols are young celebrities who's fanbase is mostly teens. the 2010s had no shortage of them, think selena gomez, justin bieber, taylor swift, demi lovato, and of course 1......   reply

i mean if liam would still be alive sure, no doubt!! but erm.. cant see that happening in any scenario.. ever.. he was the backbone in vocals, i dont think they would b able to do it without him honestly (its been 9 months and 5 days im going to kill myself)   2 reply