Gift ideas for your partner???

Okay my bf's bday is coming soon and he specifically told me he didn't want anything expensive so I thought of arts and crafts, like origami and stuff because he likes sentimental things. He's really fascinated by specially star shaped things, he gave me an awesome monthsary gift which is cake. Now I can also bake too like I can't decide between food or scrapbook of our pics or making a cake, maybe even heart churros (idk if i can SOMEHOW make them into star shapes) or wtv cus he's sweet tooth too. Arts and crafts feels too childish for our ages I mean he's older than me, still like I have a really great idea for one. I can also crochet btw so maybe that cus he likes key chains too. Idk what do I do to not make him disappointed