Responses

While I do agree that people can date whomever they want, granted that it's by mutual consent. I never said it was wrong for them to date, just that their lack of communication and honesty lead to some pain and misunderstandings. And that I felt they were both to blame for the situation in their relationship (third parties aside).
While it's not good to lie or avoid talking about your past with your partner, it's also not right to not talk about having faith or rather trust in your partner when you find out their past (slut shaming aside). Idk this whole situation just felt wrong on both their sides.