Hmmm

Tbh... I never like claude... I despise him..idk why maybe...ahhh... Arghh whats wrong with me?

I can totally relate.. I just fucking love claude but sometimes when I remember what he did to athy I become Like I am such a psycho why the do I love him

Same, I never liked Claude and I couldn’t get into the story it just wasn’t to my liking but this is my opinion so please don’t hate on me(づ￣ ³￣)づ

Waittt... isn’t The Who made me a princess a transmigration plot, that’s a complete diff person/soul whereas this manga is a reincarnation... with this one she reincarnated and bought all her trauma and pain from her previous life.
Ana in wmap did not go through that exp she’s another soul from another world who fell into a romance novel plot..

Um, well you see I saw a video about how Claude grew up like from child to adult, I saw how his face and emotions started to change like a little music edit vid and it made me realize how truly sad his past it. Sure it doesn't justify his actions for doing those things but like what tia said here "he never received love so he doesn't know how to give" but i mean really, he went through a lot.

Lol I mean why are you comparing the stories like that. look I mean yeah Claude was fucked up for killing his own daughter true. But ima say this, he felt nothing for her in her first life cause when he first met athy his memories of Diana were long gone. So he doesn’t remember anyone giving birth to athy. That’s why he was an ass. In The second life as athy, she meets her dad at age..what 5? Claude still had memories of Diana that’s why he acts so different compared to the first life. plus he didn’t necessarily favored her because he blamed her for killing Diana. And Jeanette to me was annoying in the first life like girl can’t you see your supposed “sister” is wanting the same affection you want and you don’t do nothing ugh..anyways

Now the other story ruve whatever you call him blue haired prince. Okay this story idk how to feel cause I read the book and honestly it’s way better than the manhwa. ruve was pitiful asf in the first life he was misled, poisoned, and betrayed sense childhood. He did love Tia but he just didn’t believe that Tia loved him back sense she always weared a emotionless face and never really said I love you to him he thought she only married him to have babies and use him and that she was power hungry. for him it was okay as long as she was by his side. so when the other chick comes in and she’s really warm to him and tells him she loves him. He’s feels better about himself. and the poison he drinks just makes him much worse. and in the end he kills the women he truly loved the most. honestly sucks for blue hair prince. but I honestly thought she would get revenge. yet in the end they fell for each other cause their soulmates.

they both did fucked up shit yes but they fucked up by one being poisoned and misled while the other one chose to lose memories of the person he loved

But rauve didn't receive any love growing up too and his father was always harsh on him though ?

SPOILER!! don't wanna spoil for you but athanasia in this timeline is the same athanasia from The first timeline but she lost her memory and was born again in the modern world then killed herself and somehow returned to her original world where claude but she doesn't remember any of this and thinks it's a novel

So in the end they are similar.. they both suffered in their first life and they both changed in the second timeline .. so I do think they are comparable

I also read both novels and I know everything about them and I do think you're right the novel is way better than the webtoon

Guys I want to clarify this I don't Like how Tia ended up with ruve and I think the art and the story got messed up after a while but I just couldn't Ignore this feeling about claude and ruve situations being a bit Similar and yet ruve is hated and claude is loved .. even me myself can't find an answer since I love claude .

Yeah and claude received zero love from anyone too, even the one who promised to stay by his side literally betrayed him with his brother. I felt so sad for him,

And ruve might not receive the attention he needed as a child.

I feel like the difference was really how they were portrayed in both stories. Claude was cold and unfeeling towards Athy but u didn't end feeling he was a completely bad person without hope. Ruve on the other hand was just horrible. We saw the rape, abuse, and cruelty that went on, which automatically would upset anyone. It also made him seem unredeemable to most

woah really? aah that makes me feel sad:(

idk man...Claude is A FATHER. It’s both horrible since he abused her. We can’t take child abuse lightly too! (●'◡'●)ﾉ

Well whenever I hear someone mention claude, they always talk about his looks. Compared to Ruve where this art and story is not much about character details....Basically they just give Claude a pass since he’s “good looking”. Hate to break it to you, but this is just how a lot of people are- :((

Yep totally... I kinda hate the facts that people can ignore everything just because hes hawt.. bruh...

But ruve literally was being brainwashed since he was seven that aristia is a bad, evil,silfesh and greedy and that she wants to to marry ruve just to be empress.. And ruve trusted lord Jenna blindly because he was the only one who cared for him in his entire life.. And don't ignore the fact that ruve was being drugged and poisoned for a long long time which made paranoid and mentally unstable.. He loved Tia very much but this Jenna kept filling his mind with the thought the she is cold and evil.. And was really cold to be honest and never tried to express herself properly to anyone and hated both ruve and jieun because she believed that it was her right to be the empress.. I am not justifying his actions but ruve WASN'T UNREDEEMABLE but on the contrary he just needed therapy and someone who cares for him.. And I just Don't understand why everybody hates second time line ruve although he was a totally different person who does not even know or remembered what happened in the first timeline.. I don't know man.. I really think that both of them had a very miserable life and died a miserable death.. And I really think he reedemed himself perfectly in the second timeline though.

I love this comment!!! Ruve has gone through so much and once you’re brainwashed, it’s hard to get it out. Ruve was so considerate in the second timeline, so kind and thoughtful. They’re not the same people! Those toxic people just like to hold grudges and they can’t see the story clearly. #－.－)