Hhhh it's so hard because my heart feels bad whenever Helena shows up but shes actually ju...

Shes pure but she doesnt know where to draw the line. Which can be annoying, typical fl novel but we dont do that here in the modern world mindset. Her character reminds me of janette from who made me a princess and rashta from remaried empress

First Janette is craving for affection. She doesn't get all the attention which is why she is the loneliest girl compared to Athy.
Secondly Rashta is fully aware of what she is doing. This is her way of revenge.
And she doesn't even get the love of everyone else apart of Shovieshit (that I hate way more than Rashta actually)

Anyway, all to say that Helena isn't at all like them. Helena isn't a villainess appearing as a saint. She is just a simpleton spoiled all her life. She isn't craving for attention since she already got it since birth. She is just used to it and cannot understand by herself this.

well it's not athy's fault , that the Duke locked her

Did I say it was Athy's fault? I just said "compared" lol comparing two situations.

oops I got it wrong , sorry

To me i think rashta is unaware what shes doing until later on.

My point was these characters are similar but not the same. They are similar due to them wanting to be close to the actual FL with good intention but not really taking no as an answer (except janette which athy was willimg to accept her)

I see, that's indeed a valuable reason to think they are alike. (￣∇￣")