Aside from anything you said.. I would like to point out that claude DID NOT have full control as you claim.. Yes he did kill her but the man like literally cursed himself with black magic to forget diana so he didn't even remember he had a DAUGHTER until he saw her when she was 9 which was too late because the curse fully toik over him and he didn't even know why he hates her too much.. NOT DEFENDING HIM like the man killed his own daughter and if the first time line was the main story i would have hated him like hell SO. And you're saying that it's not Jeanette's fault that athanasia died.. Umm you could be right somehow but you still can't deny that she's fucking stupid and naive in both timelines to the point where i wanna beat the hell out of her sometimes.. And if she was just a little bit less selfish and all about 'oh why no body loves' phase all of this wouldn't have happened.. Intentionally or not.. This girl drove both claude and athanasia to their death in the first timeline.. AND I'M GONNA BE HATED FOR THIS I KNOW.. BUT I JUST DON'T LIKE HER
no one blames claude for what happened in athy’s first life. he was the one who chose to neglect and later murder his own child. he was the one who had control over everything. instead they blame jennette for not helping athy. like what the fuck could she even do?? she was powerless against claude. she had no control over what claude did.
“she didn’t say athy was innocent when she got framed for poisoning her”. she was unconscious you stupid motherfuckers. she couldn’t claim athy was innocent. when she woke up athy was probably already killed by her own father.
(and i’m talking about the manhwa. the manhwa is different from the novel and has been for a long time)