wtf you even saying? "He practically killed her?" WTF She killed herself with the gun bc she thought Oscar gave her that gun. Carcel giving her that gun doesn't mean he killed her. Learn to read.
It's kind of a metaphor by giving her the gun he opened up a way for her to kill herself of which he would have lived with the guilt his whole entire 1st life
errr do u know what interpretation is?? im not saying he KILLED her im describing it in a way that HE probably felt, he probably feels like her INDIRECTLY killed her by giving her the gun but also practically saved her because the gun was the sole thing that was able to get her out of that horrible situation
Exactly sorry i didnt see your comment
He would nvr think he saved her when he only wants her to live. The way you word it is like saying he killed her just bc he gave her the gun. Are you going to say Luciano practically killed her too bc her brother gave her the bullet she used?
i think u might be a bit slow, i literally just explained what i meant by saying that so pls go back and read again cus 39 other ppl liked my original comment cus they know what i was trying to imply
Exactly he would never think he saved her (that’s what the op commentator thinks not what he thinks) he would think he contributed to her killing herself bc she used his gun and he would have felt guilty the whole time. That’s exactly what ines is describing in the latest chapter hoping that he didn’t care much about her bc if he had loved her which he did it would have eaten him up. You literally have all the pieces but are too dumb to put it together lmfao
You’re so rude! The fact is the OP’s statement is framed as if it’s her opinion, not Carcel’s, when she said ‘he practically killed her but saved her from Oscar’. Saying the person above is dumb when clearly she interpreted the statement correctly purely from what was written is like the pot calling the kettle black. If that statement was written properly in the first place, there woukdbt be any need to further explain what the writer originally meant. Upvotes also doesn’t meant a voter entirely agree with the original post. They may just like the post because they like some of the content.
Girlie I don’t care lmfao the ops statement is clear enough for anyone that has reading comprehension to clearly understand it properly. Not our fault yall can’t use your brains
Girlie, an English teacher would give a big fat F for that comprehension. You all hear acting like mediocrity is fine. No wonder so many of you all do not understand this story.
Lmao you make me crack up I think I’m doing just fine graduating from an ivy this year
well clearly ur the one who doesnt have reading comprehension because 42 people liked my original comment meaning they clearly understood what i meant by that statement.... i mean u know what implicit and explicit meanings are right??? my statement has an explicit meaning to it
implicit meaning to it i mean*
its literally just all up to interpretation so idc if yall r slow and dont get it
Bro you’re not helping your reading comprehension argument when you just went ahead and interpreted me fighting against someone who was against you as me somehow attacking you?. I clearly stated that “OPs ie original posters statement is clear enough” and even explained to someone else who didn’t get it lmfao this is cracking me up bro I really hope u just replied tot he wrong person lol
OH NOT U GIRLIE I MEANT THE OTHER PERSON
sorry tuna i mean to reply to the other person who wasnt understanding my original comment
Yea you jsut replied directly to me lol glad my hopes were right at least lol
Look here, Carcel wouldn't think he killed her just bc he gave her the gun. All he'll feel is guilt for giving her that gun but not from thinking he killed her. That's where you're wrong and you said "he practically killed her" so idk how ppl will think that's you thinking Carcel will think that. It sounded more like your opinion there especially when you said he also saved her after that bc he wouldn't think he saved her either. Ines is the one who thinks that she was freed when she told him she was raped. After she told that to him, she felt finally free bc she had not been able to tell anyone else the truth before so he's the first and last person she ever told that to and that freed her.
honestly will not be explaining this to u again after 3 other ppl explained it... lets just say u have a pea sized brain and leave it at that
i love how she reflects on fragments of her past life and notices little details that she never did like how Carcel actually blushed when he first gave her the gun but she was too distracted to notice it in her first life, so sweet and pure :')) but also really sad that we'll never be able to hear first life Carcel's thoughts and what he went through after Ines kills herself with the gun that he gave her, i genuinely cant imagine how he felt when he heard that :( he practically killed her but also saved her from Oscar