I don’t have the artistic knowledge to explain it, but I hate the way this is shaded. Th...

MangaMoon August 12, 2024 9:18 pm

I don’t have the artistic knowledge to explain it, but I hate the way this is shaded. The art is really pretty, the colors are weird.

Someone who is an artist please give me some vocabulary to express my opinion correctly.

Responses
    ghitabn August 12, 2024 9:26 pm

    I get the same vibe actually it just feels a bit too unnatural, unlike her other manhwas like bye-bye it s well drawn and colored. In this one i see that she improved her drawing but it feels like she s trying too hard to make them feel alive

    shiroji August 12, 2024 9:48 pm

    probably the shading mode that the artist/author uses is in the wrong settings i feel... like the shading does not get light enough, cold enough, warm enough, or dark enough according to their environment. but its their art and it still looks beautiful overall in the end. who are we to judge when we are just her audience? who chose to read this of our own volition xD. i think i understand what you are trying to say tho.

    MangaMoon August 13, 2024 12:59 am
    probably the shading mode that the artist/author uses is in the wrong settings i feel... like the shading does not get light enough, cold enough, warm enough, or dark enough according to their environment. but ... shiroji

    I’m a reader. Any art released publicly is open to scrutiny. Her art is good. I don’t like the colors. I promise you another chapter will still come out next week.

    MangaMoon August 13, 2024 12:59 am
    I get the same vibe actually it just feels a bit too unnatural, unlike her other manhwas like bye-bye it s well drawn and colored. In this one i see that she improved her drawing but it feels like she s tryin... ghitabn

    Yeah, it feels too dark, or bold or something. The characters are beautifully drawn, something just always feels off about the colors.

    shiroji August 13, 2024 2:36 am
    I’m a reader. Any art released publicly is open to scrutiny. Her art is good. I don’t like the colors. I promise you another chapter will still come out next week. MangaMoon

    I did not mean to say that you are not allowed to criticise her art. It was more of a general statement-I was agreeing that something is off with the shading, just that ig we can't really do anything about it ┗( T﹏T )┛please do not take my comment the wrong way!

    shiroji August 13, 2024 2:37 am
    I did not mean to say that you are not allowed to criticise her art. It was more of a general statement-I was agreeing that something is off with the shading, just that ig we can't really do anything about it ... shiroji

    I definitely worded my original comment wrong so, my apologies op. Σ(  ̄□ ̄||)