it’s wild how the artist dropped the ball as hard as they did. when you read the novel t...

5678876dfghvf78 May 21, 2025 9:01 am

it’s wild how the artist dropped the ball as hard as they did. when you read the novel there’s no way you’d end up wanting him with anyone other than shinje, but the artist barely cared about the novel or the actual main couple and it shows. a really shitty adaption to a novel i loved.

Responses
    5678876dfghvf78 May 21, 2025 9:03 am

    i wish i lived in the alternate universe where the artists who adapted roses and champagne or passion were the ones to adapt profundus. i’ll be mad as hell about it forever.

    AXCEL May 21, 2025 9:36 am

    Really?!
    I'm so gonna read that after finishing thia adaptation!

    ELLE May 21, 2025 10:41 am

    I so get you. This adaptation was not really "it" because I honestly love the dynamic of yugeon with shinje in the novel. I would hundred times read the novel all over again than this manhwa adaptation

    Greenposamari May 21, 2025 11:51 am

    Isn’t shinje who he’s with now?

    ELLE May 21, 2025 1:50 pm
    Isn’t shinje who he’s with now? Greenposamari

    Yeah but the adaptation didn't really give a justice on their story

    5678876dfghvf78 May 21, 2025 2:30 pm
    I so get you. This adaptation was not really "it" because I honestly love the dynamic of yugeon with shinje in the novel. I would hundred times read the novel all over again than this manhwa adaptation ELLE

    fr the artist skipped over every cute scene where we were shown how shinje feels about yugeon, didn’t add nearly as much internal dialogue as they should’ve since they kept skipping the small moments that showed character development, completely hollowed out yugeon and made him seem like he had no backbone and no toughnesss. such a let down… tbh i feel bad toward the author of the novel because if my work was handled like this i’d be so upset.

    Greenposamari May 22, 2025 3:54 am
    Yeah but the adaptation didn't really give a justice on their story ELLE

    Ohh ok

    Lanzhou May 23, 2025 1:32 pm

    damn that's really sad, i haven't read it but as a novel truther, it really angers me when adaptations don't do the og text justice so i absolutely understand how you feel. i get annoyed by even the tiniest changes in adaptations like THIS WAS NOT HOW IT WAS IN THE OG hope more people will read your and other novel readers comments and pick up the novel. i wouldn't want a story i like to be known only as the shitty adaptation

    Anonymous May 23, 2025 8:29 pm

    Kinda out of topic, but is this nearly the end of the story? Cuz it looked like so