Not another rape story please…

Cruchy_rollers June 16, 2025 11:51 pm

I can just, *sniffs*, smell the rape. Hopefully my senses betray me, I like the art.

Responses
    Star June 18, 2025 5:48 pm

    That's an odd thing to say. What makes you think so?

    Cruchy_rollers June 18, 2025 8:55 pm
    That's an odd thing to say. What makes you think so? Star

    First of all, it’s not odd when 90% of bl these days have rape STAR, secondly, the uke just looks super bruised and looks like he’s gonna get raped, ok? The seme doesnt look much like a green flag either

    Star June 19, 2025 3:59 am
    First of all, it’s not odd when 90% of bl these days have rape STAR, secondly, the uke just looks super bruised and looks like he’s gonna get raped, ok? The seme doesnt look much like a green flag either Cruchy_rollers

    it's kinda weird to say yeah. a person being a masochist doesn't make having sex with them rape. also the "uke" is the seme and, again, a masochist. i think you shouldn't say stuff like that unless the dynamic is very weird from the start because as of now, the mcs seem to be enemies but not like insane (at least from what i can see).

    STEWIE June 20, 2025 1:16 pm
    it's kinda weird to say yeah. a person being a masochist doesn't make having sex with them rape. also the "uke" is the seme and, again, a masochist. i think you shouldn't say stuff like that unless the dynamic ... Star

    u must be new here, then. 98% of bl-yaoi started as good and i tell you, they always— ALWAYS include rape scene once the story's become interesting. :)))

    Star June 20, 2025 11:08 pm
    u must be new here, then. 98% of bl-yaoi started as good and i tell you, they always— ALWAYS include rape scene once the story's become interesting. :))) STEWIE

    Stewie, I did not defend you in that comment thread for you to betray me like this.... i thought we were homies am i so wrong for thinking someone jumping to conclusions about a story being a rape story is strange?

    Star June 20, 2025 11:13 pm
    u must be new here, then. 98% of bl-yaoi started as good and i tell you, they always— ALWAYS include rape scene once the story's become interesting. :))) STEWIE

    Also, realistically, I do kind of see their point, but this person seems like they're pressed and are making a lot of bad assumptions based on dynamics in real life. masochists exist and the masochist in this story is a top, which makes the setup very "unrapey" as a plot point. ig it may be possible, but that sort of judgment before any red flags seems very weird. imagine you were an author trying to create a webtoon and people told you it stnak of rape when it was just a sadist/masochist plot-driven bl. im just saying dont judge before an ACTUAL red flag comes up.

    STEWIE June 21, 2025 7:24 am
    Also, realistically, I do kind of see their point, but this person seems like they're pressed and are making a lot of bad assumptions based on dynamics in real life. masochists exist and the masochist in this s... Star

    if you see the point, then why are you still debating? you can’t claim to get it while trying to reframe the convo as ‘weird’ or ‘unfair.’ it’s not about real-life BDSM, it’s about how predictable BL tropes are. sorry if calling it early offends you, but history’s on our side. :ppp

    Star June 25, 2025 2:48 am
    if you see the point, then why are you still debating? you can’t claim to get it while trying to reframe the convo as ‘weird’ or ‘unfair.’ it’s not about real-life BDSM, it’s about how predictable... STEWIE

    ong stewie i asked a question about why they thought so and made a point about how not all masochist representation is rape. i don't understand why you got so worked up that i am willing to believe BLs MAY have started to move past rape even a tiny bit, is it wrong to have hope or are you trying to crush that too.

    i just think it's weird to label things as "rape" for no real reason. idk why you're so determined to believe this bl will have rape but i guess old people are more stagnated in beliefs. anywho... have a nice night

    Cruchy_rollers June 25, 2025 3:03 am
    ong stewie i asked a question about why they thought so and made a point about how not all masochist representation is rape. i don't understand why you got so worked up that i am willing to believe BLs MAY have... Star

    Mf I ain’t old tf

    Star June 25, 2025 3:07 am
    Mf I ain’t old tf Cruchy_rollers

    hey dumbfuck, if you try using your eyes you'd notice i replied to stewie not you. hope that helps!

    Cruchy_rollers June 25, 2025 3:27 am
    hey dumbfuck, if you try using your eyes you'd notice i replied to stewie not you. hope that helps! Star

    You said “idk why you're so determined to believe this bl will have rape but i guess old people are more stagnated in beliefs” which can apply to both of us stupid.

    Star June 25, 2025 3:46 am
    You said “idk why you're so determined to believe this bl will have rape but i guess old people are more stagnated in beliefs” which can apply to both of us stupid. Cruchy_rollers

    if the shoe fits

    Cruchy_rollers June 25, 2025 11:43 am
    if the shoe fits Star

    You came to MY comment and started arguing but ok

    Star June 25, 2025 8:35 pm
    You came to MY comment and started arguing but ok Cruchy_rollers

    no, i asked you a question and was respectful to you until you called me an "mf." you wanna spit some out? lick it up too hoe.

    STEWIE June 26, 2025 3:23 pm
    ong stewie i asked a question about why they thought so and made a point about how not all masochist representation is rape. i don't understand why you got so worked up that i am willing to believe BLs MAY have... Star

    nahhh, just to clarify where i stand— i do see both points here. you're right that jumping to conclusions too fast can feel unfair, especially when the story hasn't shown clear signs yet. but I also think it's fair (and honestly kind of normal) for bl readers like the op to express concern early on, especially since a lot of these stories do eventually introduce rape plots even when they start off fine.

    it isn't about assuming every masochist = non-consensual situation, but more about how certain visual or narrative cues often do foreshadow those problematic scenes, based on pattern and history. that doesn’t mean this story will go that way, but i think pointing out the worry isn’t weird it’s actually a form of hopeful caution. we shouldn’t just ignore that bl as a genre has a track record that makes readers wary. i think the op was just hoping that this one breaks the pattern which i backed.