Apparently he has been named Faux, so far by fans
He HAS TO BE Ciel anyway. Every now and then he remembers his past life with his family and aunt, so he IS Ciel Phantomhive. God I hope the new one is not his twin but an imposter or someting -.- I hate it. First Agni. Now this.
If he's Ciel's twin of course he would have memories of his family. They both share the same family after all.
I hope the names of the twins are linked ^.^ Ciel means Sky in french, so who knows...
I was a believer of the twins theory before, and I don't know how you cannot believe it with chapter 129.
On the other hand, as much as I love this plot twist, I hope our Ciel will still be referred as "Ciel" by the others (even if I'm dying to know his real name!)
Yes, but why wouldn't Ciel be Ciel then?? Cause fine, then he has that stupid twin :p (no fan of this theory) but he should still be Ciel and his brother has his own name.
And if he is his twin, there are a looot of moments that don't make any sense. Let's not talk about the fact that NOONE ever mentions his lost brother, but when Madame remembered the past there was also just one boy. And wasn't there a newspaper after the murder of his parents saying the (like one) boy is missing.
Ah no use talking about it, we'll see. I hope it's not true. No idea why, but I just HATE it and would love for him to disappear SOON.
PS. I still this the mangaka just made a mistake in the beginning drawing the moments of Ciels month in captivity differently :D
In Madam Red's flashback they were outside. Our!Ciel was probably sickly inside (asthma, kind of like in This Butler, Nursing where he said he couldn't go on a trip with them at the very end because he got too sickly). Also at their birth the panels can be interpreted as Madam Red got to hold one while Rachel had the other one at her side.
The newpaper probably told they were all missing, as both of them were missing for a month or two until Our!Ciel lowkey reappeared.
No one ever mentions HIM, the sickly one. There was no use to bring up the sickly one, Ciel was the one who was going to inherit the title so everything was fine. The story also starts out one year after so they might've asked before for a short while and who knows that may be a flashback Yana is saving up.
The thing is that it's Our!Ciel that has another name. He took his brother's name and Sebastian even laughs at him practically each time he says "I'm Ciel Phantomhive" at the beginning of the story and even comments a few time that he seems to be quite the liar when he first says it (presumably knowing he really wasn't Ciel).
I really hope that's not true though. Don't like it at ALL -.-
Even if you're not a fan of the twin theory, I prefer you should read it because ALL your questions will be answered there. Then you'll say... "Oh, I see" and about our!Ciel's real name, his name isn't Ciel because whenever he says who is the heir of the Phantomhives is "Ciel Phantomhive" with " " and he doesn't say I am Ciel Phantomhive, the heir of the Phantomhive because in reality he isn't, he is the little brother of the REAL Ciel Phantomhive.
Even if you don't like the twin theory, you should really read it because it is confirmed that theory is TRUE. I may sound being rude but I still don't lile that people won't accept the fact that the theory is already true despite Chapter 129 releasing and if people don't accept its as if you're calling Yana-sensei a joker that released a chapter with Ciel having a twin as a joke. I think that's rude to the author since she already REVEALED HINTS in the previous chapters and most fans figured this out who believed the twin theory.
Of course I'll read it, I simply don't like it. Just as I hate that Agni died. Right now it annoys me all xD
And, well, I don't see that the theory is proven to be right by 100%. Maybe highly likely, yes, but not proven yet. So I still have a little hope, even if it's just by... like... 5%.And only for another month :D aaah man.
Bring Agni back and I'll try to like this twist.
Plus. I might come to like it when ourCiel shows that he is "stronger" and better then the newOne.
Btw where and why was he gone all this time? Why return now. And with such an attitude.
I know, no questions anyone can answer yet :) just wondering out loud.
Why isn't anyone asking the real question : WHAT IS OUR CIEL'S TRUE NAME???