I thought ML was just flirting with Rosie and maybe he had no physical relationship with h...

No offense but this is fiction with probably very different circumstances than your friend

At the beginning it was already made clear that he had slept with Rose in his previous life so I don't know why you are surprised.

When and where . I didn't remember omg . Thanks for letting me know

This is fiction that's why . Those men who political slept with their seniors to gain power are right? There many examples out there . Where the men is already dating company owner daughter but the father is strict with the men wouldn't let him promote easily so those men slept with senior authorities to get opportunities. Even though they loved their current partner. Those type should be forgiven? . What if fl in her new life would choose ml as her only business partner . Would the ml wouldn't do the same? Or if fl becomes useless?
If this is a fictional story . Then the emperor from empress remarriage manhua should be forgiven too? There are many shitty ml . then you should forgive them too

Sorry for my English. I'm not good in it

And dear trust me stay away from such men who can sleep with anyone. If you learn to forgive such people in the world of fiction, then gradually you will start doing the same in real life also. Such a person initially loves the other person a lot, but then slowly the love starts decreasing or they stay together for a long time, then they start cheating. Future life is not shown in fictional stories, otherwise after a long time such ML become scumbag .

Rose was pregnant and also all knights are supposed to be inspected by their royals. Usually the same night they have been partnered up.

I think Syl was somehow saved by the ML the moment he stepped in to steal his position. I somehow glad he did.

I cannot understand the meaning behind comparing real life issues with stories, but because real life issues usually have more complex situations than these fictional stories.

Sorry I cannot relate with your situation, but better than saying "don't be with people that do this", it is better to say that you should find somebody who is trustworthy, somebody who really fits your morals. Even if you consider this "bad behaviour", there are some people that do not mind.

It is just my opinion of course, buy you have here quite the nice topic of conversation (づ￣ ³￣)づ

Be happy and hugs for everyone

You do realize he’s a slave right? If he wasn’t doing this he’d still be chained down somewhere, or killed. This clearly isn’t a situation he’d choose if he had other options.

I guess I misunderstood it because of they way the artist have drawn his "leaving" from the castle, as if he was a human commoner. However, it is true that homunculus always have to do hardwork, if they are not guardians, they should be mining.

Thanks for the reminder :D

Isn't that just his past self that he doesnt remember even happening? The situation was different back then too. Just asking btw

Rosie got pregnant by him. It was in the intro.

In the same intro it was also shown that Rosie had goten pregnant throught some magical method as it wouldn’t have been possible by the oldfashioned way because humunculy are not human. AND more importantly she wasn’t pregnant by Michael, we don’t know who’s sperm they used but not Michael.
(Sorry, not trying to correct you specifically but everyone seemed to have forgotten so many details and this was the best place to mention this.)

Yep, that's true. In fact Rosie's pregnancy was rejected by the ML because it was an experiment, not a "child".

To be honest I agree with what you said
That type of ML or person is not trustworthy. But let's consider the circumstances. Humonculos is not treated like equal to human.And thus, if you could see how Sylvester is really uncomfortable with rosie because he need to sleep with her.You could see the disgust he fellt but he have no choice. That is why he keep asking ML if he and eve is doing such things. Then he realized Eve is not that person. She is the only royal who truly care for Humonculos.

And lets just think it happened in his past life.because he nèeded to do that just to be near to eve. Even him is disgusted when he saw his past self.
It just show the devotion he had. Let's not forget he rebel and lead the humonculos when they tried to send eve to faraway kingdom for marriage.
The way he always wanted to be choosen by eve but she said she will not choose any humonculos. Him being self aware unlike other humonculos but still want to be with eve.

Their tragic lovestory in the past deserve to flourish in this present life.

P.S ofcourse in real life or othee story if your man can't keep his self from sleeping with other people. Have some respect for yourself and stay away from that.Choose someone who have the same values and mindset as you.so that even if sparks of love is gone. Still the values and his moral is intact.

If sylvester were to be ML or the king of humonculos w then he would never have chosen this path where he had to play a game of love with the rose or has toseduce her for the power . Sylvester definitely chose some other way. Nor would he have to achieve success by pleasing one women. (︶︿︶)＝凸

Sylvester is lovely and must be loved. I am going to start a cult.

Count me in . Silvy is best ,

Yeah, I felt so sorry for him. He is clearly feeling sexually abuse by rosie.because the disgust he feel steemed from being seen as peasant and sexual object that can be used however by that b**ch princess!! I don't want her for sylvester that is why I don't like it when I learn from a novel spoiler that she seem to regret and want to cherish sylvester. So she is pursuing him.But,No b**ch!! Stay away from him you deserve no love in this life. He

So, join our cult. We love Sylvester :D

Also, I think the way they have explained the story is pretty good: at first you didn't have the feels of why they were rebelling against humans. Now you have all the reasons to join the homunculus party xD