I really don’t understand why manhwas are rated so high in this website when comparing t...

ADMK September 4, 2025 4:29 pm

I really don’t understand why manhwas are rated so high in this website when comparing to mangas
This one, for example, is so plain… nothing too special about the plot, the art, or character development
Sorry to make this comment here, it could be almost any manhwa, I just had to get this out of my system

Responses
    thakxk September 4, 2025 5:46 pm

    then dont come here likeeee tf

    Luka September 4, 2025 6:09 pm

    You can drop it. Like really you can, just drop it and go read mangas. That'll be your safe place I guess...

    Marasmius September 4, 2025 6:27 pm

    Honestly after 13 years of reading bl, this now is one of my favorite, I don't need crazy plots and red flag characters all the time. Sometimes I feel we say this is or that trope is "cliches" even tho it's kinda rare to find, cuz everyone wanna be different from the cliches, and people say it's boring but for ducks sake cuz if mentality we don't see this tropes anymore ( off topic but I feel the same with fantasy, after a while every author wanted to be different from the originally and because if this the classics are lost, an everyone is the same ) still, you have your right to have your opinion, I just wanted to answer why for example so many people likes classic "boring" story lines, anyway, if u need any recommendations what is not this "average" just text me, if I can I am happy to give some recommendations so you can find something for your taste as well

    kinda_judgemental September 4, 2025 6:30 pm

    personally, I think there's so many bad ones that this one shines maybe more than it deserves, but it's probably me reading too many :)) I do know what you mean, I feel like many people don't understand that giving it 2 or 3 stars still means it's mediocre, since it's 2 or 3 out out 5, and they feel like they're saying something is really bad woth the 2 or 3 stars

    Guerrilla Girl September 4, 2025 7:38 pm

    Art style/color plays a huge part in readability for general audiences tbhhh

    kokona September 4, 2025 10:53 pm

    It probably has something to do with the length of the story and also the consistent update from the manhwa authors.
    Unlike most mangas with mostly 5-7 chapters per volume.
    Sometimes a chapter took fucking months or eve years to update with no schedule/information abou when it will come back and the most annoying thing is when you get a good manga then you find out the manga hasn't been update since forever cause the author dropped it or whatever reasons.
    How do you expect people to remember the stories that way haha

    ADMK September 5, 2025 12:07 am
    It probably has something to do with the length of the story and also the consistent update from the manhwa authors. Unlike most mangas with mostly 5-7 chapters per volume. Sometimes a chapter took fucking mont... kokona

    I think this is what explains it best
    Plus some other reasons people mentioned above
    I knew this was going to be an unpopular comment
    Calm down people
    I’m not saying it’s bad or that I don’t like reading it, just that the rating is higher than I’d expect it to be
    There’s also the problem that we can rate from 1-5 stars but the final score is 1-10… we should be able to vote from 1-10, the range is better

    ADMK September 5, 2025 12:10 am
    Honestly after 13 years of reading bl, this now is one of my favorite, I don't need crazy plots and red flag characters all the time. Sometimes I feel we say this is or that trope is "cliches" even tho it's kin... Marasmius

    Thanks for giving me a nice answer! That’s also a valid opinion, as is everyone’s in here and I see what you mean!
    Let me know if you have something you’d recommend on top of your mind!

    its not that deep September 5, 2025 7:37 am

    it's cause it's a slow burn and the tension is what is making it good for the lot of us. like were excited and anticipating. that's a great place to be for a story.

    its not that deep September 5, 2025 7:39 am
    it's cause it's a slow burn and the tension is what is making it good for the lot of us. like were excited and anticipating. that's a great place to be for a story. its not that deep

    we're*

    Fumiii September 5, 2025 12:30 pm

    Yeah we here for the greenest flag Ian not like those TOXIC red flags who , tortures bottoms mentally ( ̄へ ̄)

    kokona September 5, 2025 3:17 pm
    I think this is what explains it bestPlus some other reasons people mentioned aboveI knew this was going to be an unpopular comment Calm down peopleI’m not saying it’s bad or that I don’t like reading it... ADMK

    It happened to me like so many times
    It's so annoying that decided to drop those mangas. I am still waiting for Koimonogatari though, can't believe there's still no update till now ╥﹏╥

    And I also think people are just genuinely into colored comics more. I noticed that most non-colored manhwas have less readers than the colored ones. Even when the non-colored ones have better storyline and art style, they most likely still losing popularity