Look man

It's not even about Aisha-forgiving-Marianne that got people all mad (I mean yeah that's part of the reason for quite a lot), it's that if you reread, you'll notice so many things that 'Alisa' said in the beginning before and after she was executed stop making sense.

There was a huge emphasis on 'Alisa' having hair as black as crow and green dirty eyes, BECAUSE

SPOILER
.
.
.
.
SPOILER FROM NOVEL YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED
.
.
THAT BLACK HAIR FAKA IS MARRIANE THIS ENTIRE TIME, NOT ALISA


Marriane stole Alisa's appearance.
That means Mari is supposed to have black hair green eyes.
While Alisa's the loca with silver hair gold eyes.

Mari stole Alisa's identity, brainwashed Alisa's entire family, framed Alisa, and get Alisa executed by the ones she loved most, ALL WHILE WEARING HER FACE. (Yeah it also makes no sense for Alisa to forgive Marianne, people like to frame forgiving as a strong quality, but try living in Alisa's shoes and say it again.)

(Also even if Aisha forgives her past-family, what makes yall think Yvis would spare them when he's the kinda faka that would burn an entire country for his sister, dood so ride-or-die with his fam we lucky he has this thing called empathy, otherwise...)

AND MARIANNE WAS NOT TREATED POORLY BY THE MAIDS
IDK WHY SHE MADE IT ALL UP EITHER

THE WHOLE APPEARANCE SWITCHING IS ALSO PART OF WHY NOW-AISHA WAS WTF-ING PTSD-ING WHEN SHE REBORN INTO A WHITE HAIR FAKA

IDK MAN, NOVEL READERS, PLEASE APPEAR NOW AND BESTOW UPON US YO WISDOM AND CORRECT ME IF I GOT ANYTHING WRONG

People think we mad coz revenge aint revenging, NAAAAWH MAN that's not the full reason! It's the plot aint ploting, and chara aint chara-ing. There's so many missing shet I'm just mad we couldn't get the satisfying reveal of the FULL EXTEND what Mari actually did and made Alisa went through.