so alive and unlive people is believable, but changing the contents of the notebook is abs...

rere November 18, 2025 2:20 am

so alive and unlive people is believable, but changing the contents of the notebook is absurd...

Responses
    Sazz November 18, 2025 2:26 am

    It's not though? He can change everything in existence, from shapes to laws and people.

    rere November 18, 2025 2:36 am
    It's not though? He can change everything in existence, from shapes to laws and people. Sazz

    it's not quite what I said

    Honeet November 18, 2025 2:47 am

    Well, he was presenting believable proof while she just had just a notebook and allegedly psychological issues. He still didn't do anything to her this time to make her doubt him.

    Sazz November 18, 2025 2:59 am
    it's not quite what I said rere

    oh yes, sorry. I just skimmed what you wrote and understood something else.

    Sazz November 18, 2025 3:10 am

    So, i think that the concrete proof he always prepares, the fact that she was desperate to believe him due to the stress she went through(over the things she originally believed as the truth), plus the intense relief she felt over her parents being alive, led to her instant, momentary trust over his words.

    Anxiety + doubt + all the small things that fail to prove her memories + her need for relief, all led to this. The brain is adaptive like that for the best and for the worst. She is avoiding facing the tiny possibilities that could bring her back to doubt, hence why her face looked so desperately relieved in the end. Hope this makes sense, i tried to explain it as well as i could, gthe way i perceive it is too abstract to explain it any better.

    rere November 18, 2025 3:40 am
    Well, he was presenting believable proof while she just had just a notebook and allegedly psychological issues. He still didn't do anything to her this time to make her doubt him. Honeet

    yes, but I think that's not enough to believe him, not that fast and devoted, at least, but I think she wanted to believe him the most, and that's what really impacted

    rere November 18, 2025 3:41 am
    oh yes, sorry. I just skimmed what you wrote and understood something else. Sazz

    no prob

    rere November 18, 2025 3:42 am
    So, i think that the concrete proof he always prepares, the fact that she was desperate to believe him due to the stress she went through(over the things she originally believed as the truth), plus the intense ... Sazz

    Yes, I agree
    I was joking before, but I really think that it's her wanting to believe the most

    Qxeen_zxy November 18, 2025 5:01 am

    Nah cause what’s more believable? A cosmic horror killed and revived everyone around you day after day and systematically changed the world over and over to torture you OR you watched too much horror and your brain is misremembering it after your head injury that left you with amnesia? I’m picking brain malfunction especially since I have glitches despite my brain being perfectly fine. He’s suggesting she’s got déjà vu in the extreme which absolutely could happen. Déjà vu works because your brain processes things it’s seen or experienced as an old memory being revisited rather than a brand new blank slate. It’s the same as accidentally adding a new telephone number to an existing contact instead of creating a brand new contact number. That’s believable and scientifically proven. I don’t blame her at all.

    Sazz November 18, 2025 11:50 am
    Nah cause what’s more believable? A cosmic horror killed and revived everyone around you day after day and systematically changed the world over and over to torture you OR you watched too much horror and your... Qxeen_zxy

    The brain can even totally replace an old memory during a state where the hormones of stressed are increased. Take for example a subtype of obsessive compulsive disorder which is called "false memories ocd".

    Sazz November 18, 2025 11:50 am
    The brain can even totally replace an old memory during a state where the hormones of stressed are increased. Take for example a subtype of obsessive compulsive disorder which is called "false memories ocd". Sazz

    *hormones of stress

    Qxeen_zxy November 18, 2025 5:35 pm
    The brain can even totally replace an old memory during a state where the hormones of stressed are increased. Take for example a subtype of obsessive compulsive disorder which is called "false memories ocd". Sazz

    Yuppp and your mind can completely pretend that memories don’t exist and have never existed and will replace the whole time period with whole other narrative because of ptsd. I’ve got ptsd and although I can remember what happened to me in clear detail down to the very scent of the air around me, I cannot remember the months that happened before or after in detail and the details I remember are wrong which sucks cause I apparently wrote my final exams about a sad banana that just wants to be friends with the other fruit in the bowl lol the brain is very weird and basically a toddler gremlin

    Sazz November 18, 2025 10:17 pm
    Yuppp and your mind can completely pretend that memories don’t exist and have never existed and will replace the whole time period with whole other narrative because of ptsd. I’ve got ptsd and although I ca... Qxeen_zxy

    I have ptsd plus ocd and i can totally relate! I often treat the triggering thoughts i get as a separate little monster which helps me recognise when i'm about to spiral lol We are not our thoughts nor our experiences, we are who we choose to be!

    Nevertheless, i'm currently studying to become a psychologist (on my last year in uni) and memories is one of the most fascinating subjects.

    Qxeen_zxy November 18, 2025 11:31 pm
    I have ptsd plus ocd and i can totally relate! I often treat the triggering thoughts i get as a separate little monster which helps me recognise when i'm about to spiral lol We are not our thoughts nor our expe... Sazz

    I’m also studying psychology but specifically cause I’m so so so over cbt therapy being like “thoughts are like buses and you can choose which bus to get on…” cause my thoughts are like super sonic trains and I’m tied to the tracks they run on lmao

    I hope you find a way that helps you manage your ptsd and ocd best! I say cause everyone knows you never 100% get cured or either of those things

    Sazz November 19, 2025 12:12 am
    I’m also studying psychology but specifically cause I’m so so so over cbt therapy being like “thoughts are like buses and you can choose which bus to get on…” cause my thoughts are like super sonic tr... Qxeen_zxy

    I wholeheartedly agree. I also dislike how often a lot of therapists think "one method fits all". Every person is different and reacts differently, even if they are plagued by the same issue.

    Oh i have! In fact finding what works best by myself through research, is what pushed me to pursue the specific degree. I've been the healthiest i've ever been after practicing erp by myself. I've had quite a few unfortunate consultations with both psychologists and psychiatrists and desperation forced me to rely on myself (it also helped that psychology was kind of a hobby even before i had any thoughts of pursuing). I still do go through anxiety episodes, but it's easier to manage now that i at least have my ocd under control. These conditions may be chronic, but they are still very manageable, to the point you can have a perfectly normal life. So never give up.I wish you the best for your healing journey.

    Qxeen_zxy November 19, 2025 1:42 am
    I wholeheartedly agree. I also dislike how often a lot of therapists think "one method fits all". Every person is different and reacts differently, even if they are plagued by the same issue. Oh i have! In fact... Sazz

    Ooooo yay!!! I love hearing success stories!! I’m so proud of you!! Thank you for the encouragement!

    Sazz November 19, 2025 1:58 pm
    Ooooo yay!!! I love hearing success stories!! I’m so proud of you!! Thank you for the encouragement! Qxeen_zxy

    :)