I CAN'T REMEMBER!!! I started reading manga at the 6th grade when I was 11, I'm 25 now it's been 14 years! If I had to guess maybe Naruto or Gaara...
reading other comments rememinded me that I started watching anime LONG before I started reading manga so first 2D crush would probably be Sakura's brother Toya (or Tori in the Dub ver as a child) or Kiba from Yu-Gi-Oh.
I CAN'T REMEMBER!!! I started reading manga at the 6th grade when I was 11, I'm 25 now it's been 14 years! If I had to guess maybe Naruto or Gaara...