Responses

You have twins that are a day apart so if one was born on December 31st and one on January that could make their age difference, it's possibly translated wrong if it's not that.
And if the situation is true about the months it'd explain their different grades since there's a certain cut off month for school.
They are IDENTICAL TWINS, of course they're both handsome *face palm*
http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/in_a_heartbreak/uu/in_a_heartbreak-chapter-7/16/