I'm not even gonna argue

Amorim March 2, 2018 8:38 am

People over analyze Manga so so so so so much. You wanna know why you're not enjoying a plot? Because you are making it to be a way bigger deal than it is. Just assume the author is not tackling society's issues and flaws and just enjoy the goddamn story

Responses
    Anonymous March 2, 2018 2:27 pm

    Can’t really enjoy a shit story ┑( ̄Д  ̄)┍

    aerslevdi March 2, 2018 4:30 pm

    LOL. Your comment is spot on. I love to laugh at this one comment that says "and mangaka's get away with it" like WTF? Do you think this is a fucking bomb? Just because you have the brain process of a pea doesn't mean we can't enjoy a manga because we can distinguish between fiction and reality!

    Anonymous March 3, 2018 12:42 am
    LOL. Your comment is spot on. I love to laugh at this one comment that says "and mangaka's get away with it" like WTF? Do you think this is a fucking bomb? Just because you have the brain process of a pea doesn... aerslevdi

    LOL. You have to have the brain process of a pea to enjoy this manga.

    aerslevdi March 3, 2018 4:53 am
    LOL. You have to have the brain process of a pea to enjoy this manga. @Anonymous

    Or maybe... You know, this thing called different taste... (︶︿︶)=凸

    Anonymous March 3, 2018 4:32 pm
    Or maybe... You know, this thing called different taste... (︶︿︶)=凸 aerslevdi

    That's rich coming from someone who was criticizing people for criticizing the manga.

    aerslevdi March 3, 2018 6:42 pm
    That's rich coming from someone who was criticizing people for criticizing the manga. @Anonymous

    ( ̄へ ̄) really? Did you bother to read the comment? They aren't saying I don't like it. They are saying it's bad by judging the characters under rules that apply to real people. This is work of fiction. You either like the story or you don't, but you don't translate it to the real world and judge it according to reality because then most fictional works ( not only mangas) won't hold out. Taste is an opinion, judgement is based on facts (ideally). And the people complaining about this manga are judging by parameters that aren't relevant in a work of fiction.

    Amorim March 3, 2018 8:29 pm
    ( ̄へ ̄) really? Did you bother to read the comment? They aren't saying I don't like it. They are saying it's bad by judging the characters under rules that apply to real people. This is work of fiction.... aerslevdi

    Yeah this is basically spot on. If you don't like it you don't like it but dragging it through the mud just because you dont like the situation they created and want to bring up real stuff in a work of fiction just makes me mad. I actually really liked this Manga and I almost didn't read it because of the overly critical comments

    Anonymous March 3, 2018 11:05 pm
    ( ̄へ ̄) really? Did you bother to read the comment? They aren't saying I don't like it. They are saying it's bad by judging the characters under rules that apply to real people. This is work of fiction.... aerslevdi

    They are very well relevant in a work of fiction. How am I supposed to give a shit about the conflict presented when it's followed through so poorly? You and Amorim are free to enjoy the manga despite its flaws, but don't get upset when others don't enjoy it.

    Amorim March 3, 2018 11:24 pm
    They are very well relevant in a work of fiction. How am I supposed to give a shit about the conflict presented when it's followed through so poorly? You and Amorim are free to enjoy the manga despite its flaws... @Anonymous

    How exactly is it relevant? It's not real. I can go out and write a book about gore and rape and that's relevant to reality? I'll try one more time to state that it's fine if you didn't like the story and the rape or the age gap or whatever it was you didn't like. But everyone over analyzing this story like the author meant for the mother to appear like a shit person. You guys can clearly read words and actions but what about vibes? Did that seem like a disgusting unhappy scene to you? Really? All I'm saying I'd the author probably didn't think twice about how this story was supposed to be interpreted. They probably assumed that the cute flowery backgrounds were enough for people but for everyone here just keeps freaking out about pointless things. Not because the topics themselves are pointless but because it's FICTION. If everyone you look at a snowflake you think if crystals and condensation and which direction the wind blew to get it to where it is, you will never appreciate the snow does that make sense? Just stop over analyzing. Not everything is an attack towards a demographic. Sometimes a story is just that. A story

    Amorim March 3, 2018 11:28 pm
    How exactly is it relevant? It's not real. I can go out and write a book about gore and rape and that's relevant to reality? I'll try one more time to state that it's fine if you didn't like the story and the r... Amorim

    *Everytime you look at a snowflake

    Anonymous March 4, 2018 12:11 am
    How exactly is it relevant? It's not real. I can go out and write a book about gore and rape and that's relevant to reality? I'll try one more time to state that it's fine if you didn't like the story and the r... Amorim

    LOL. So you believe fiction should not be criticized?

    Amorim March 4, 2018 4:59 am
    LOL. So you believe fiction should not be criticized? @Anonymous

    Look I get where you're coming from but there's a difference between discussing flaws and saying "how disgusting that he was raped and the mother didn't do anything about it. Ruined it for me." That's projecting onto real world issues and I honestly think if everyone didn't get hung up on something that isn't even real you guys would enjoy the story a lot more. I've said everything I could possibly say. I even said I wasn't gonna argue lol. Anyway have a nice day and try to just read without getting too hung up on things

    aerslevdi March 4, 2018 7:12 pm
    LOL. So you believe fiction should not be criticized? @Anonymous

    By all means criticize it. But do it based on this particular work. Not bringing reality into it. This is a light-hearted manga. It wasn't meant for any more nor less than that. If you can't make that distinction then you are missing out on it. If the story had a more serious tone and the kid actually reacted as a real person, then the mother's reaction would have been way off. But it is not the case. And worst of all, you are keeping potential readers from this manga because you can't difference between reality and fiction.

    Anonymous March 4, 2018 10:01 pm
    By all means criticize it. But do it based on this particular work. Not bringing reality into it. This is a light-hearted manga. It wasn't meant for any more nor less than that. If you can't make that distincti... aerslevdi

    I am basing the criticism on this particular work. Read pages 30-45 of chapter 2 and try to tell me again that this is a light-hearted manga. Stop making it out be an issue of reality vs fiction. I like plenty of manga with unrealistic elements because of the way they're handled. This manga as I've said before does a poor job of following through with the conflict it presents.

    Shaii Otaku March 7, 2018 2:35 pm

    This story is unique (๑•ㅂ•)و✧

    Anonymous March 18, 2018 1:39 am

    You cant really enjoy something that just weirds you out no matter how hard you try ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭..but hey, people have different interests but this one aint my cup of teaヾ(❀╹◡╹)ノ~ i dont even know why i finished it

    Asakura June 26, 2018 3:19 pm

    I don't have problem with most of the yaoi tropes not being real. And ......It doesn't need to reflect society' s problems but need to have some consistency. The character personality and their reactions just don't match. For me, it was like introducing a character who is a vegetarian and showing in the next panel enjoying chicken 65- where did it come from?!

    Asakura June 26, 2018 3:21 pm
    LOL. So you believe fiction should not be criticized? @Anonymous

    ヾ(☆▽☆)

    Asakura June 26, 2018 3:31 pm
    LOL. Your comment is spot on. I love to laugh at this one comment that says "and mangaka's get away with it" like WTF? Do you think this is a fucking bomb? Just because you have the brain process of a pea doesn... aerslevdi

    I've seen many of your previous comments- you also comment about mangas who don't portray the story in a realistic way. Ex: "mangaka sometimes adds scenes to the mangas to make them more dramatic or something and they end up annoying or absurd"- can't your point also be negated by saying "it's just fiction so it doesn't need to be realistic". So it's not as simple a matter of being fiction or real. Most fiction, in fact, reflect the society, it's norms and cultures. Yaoi's have many exceptions, but they have their own way of binding things together in a way that makes sense. For instance, they are true to their character portrayal and background to match it. I think most of the negative comments are about that- Not it being a unrealistic fiction, but an illogical fiction. There is a difference. PS: not stalking, just finished the manga "Lover's Potion" and saw your comment.