I'm on vol. 5 but I think it depends on your interest. This is a slice of life isekai story and doesn't have complicated conflicts so every volume feels like it ended well. Idk about the reboot, though.
I haven't started the reboot, but if i'm not mistaken, tl said that the first volume doesn't have that much change in the plot, and would go to a different direction around vol. 3(?) (I forgot so i'm not sure anymore)
https://www.novelupdates.com/series/the-man-picked-up-by-the-gods/ - original version that is up to vol 5
https://www.novelupdates.com/series/the-man-picked-up-by-the-gods-reboot/ - new version by the same author with some unnecessary parts taken off and new material added. People that have read both recommend this one. However, the translation is still up to vol 1 for now.