As a 3rd party: I personally thought it looked great. I liked the colored pages as they put emphasis on the scenes. I'd like to point out that what you just did isn't critique, it was harassment, you didn't give any advice and you just said it looks bad. Not sure about any of the past, i'm SPECIFICALLY commenting on what you wrote here. Also, i've argued with plenty of translators, so this is my honest opinion, it's not that "mentality" that you're using to dismiss other peoples' opinions. Here is a comment within the last week where i gave my opinion without "sucking the translators dick": http://www.mangago.zone/home/mangatopic/3388384/
I genuinely just think the arts good.
Aren't you too young to be on this site?
Ungrateful dog
yeah this isn't hateful at all,
irony at it's finest lol.
Honestly this is second part of the whole harassment I've been gone through (cause if you wanna use that word the attacks have gone my way more) by the scan group and whoever wants to suck their imaginary dicks.
I gave a very vague comment at first and they all just came at me, again, I'm sorry they got super triggered cause they obs can see their coloring isn't that good and they're sensitive about it.
I'm giving as much critique on it as I can... should I link tutorials on how to color? or why burn and soft shadows are not good techniques?
I'm getting tired of trying to be as nice as I can with people going at me cause they dislike my opinions and they want to look good to people that need the attention.
Rather than the tutorials, would you be so kind as to provide a link to the comment where this all started so i can verify that you were the one attacked first?
Fan additions is a longtime part of admiring artists. Cosplay, fan fiction, fan art. Coloring the pages would generally be considered a bonus or a fan extension activity. If they weren't fans, they wouldn't be scanlating it to begin with, really, dontcha think?
I thought the pages were nicely colored, too.
When you call comments that dissent from yours--but aren't full of vulgarities--"sucking dick," you are the one taking the low ground.
Your objectively wrong if you say the pages are good.
you like them, you're grateful and that blinds your judgment.
Ad hominens are not real arguments. The way I speak is irrelevant.
Coloring will forever be disrespectful to artists, mangas are not cómic boobs nor coloring ones, you're not respecting the esthetic.
fake fans, really.
Haha boobs.... :')
my autocorrect knows me
Not paying for work is inherently disrespectful.
You cannot say "objectively wrong," since there is so much that is subjective about art. Some people love Jane Austen and some think she's boring. Some people love the Fauve movement NOW, but many artists thought it was shit when it came out.
When people say they think it's good or they like it, it's subjective, it's not an academic exercise. It's a fan reaction. Since this is a fansite, not an academic discussion of art site, the opinions on whether they like it or not, think it's good or not, are fine in that framework.
And one doesn't have to toss ad hominems to have a discussion. One doesn't have to use metaphors that are insulting to make a point. "Sucking dick" is an insult and intended to demean and that says quite a bit about YOU.
Gratitude doesn't "color" my opinion. Even if I hated all those scanlators, I still find the colored pages pleasant. I'd be equally fine if they were NOT there. No big thing either way.
It's people making a big thing out of a handful of pages that seems silly to me, frankly.
Talks about harassment
And harasses the scanlation group on every comment section
You don’t even know how to respect sb who puts effort,time and money on something for you to read illegally and for free, and here you are playing the victim
If you act like that, it means you’re too young to be on this website, or on internet at all. If you don’t wanna be *harassed* you can stop being so immature and stop making drama on every comment section :/
Yes we’ve already heard your opinions
No,stop playing the victim please it’s really starting to annoy me
They just do it because they enjoy doing it and they’re already doing you a favor, so stop
As an artist who once was a beginner, I find YOU disrespectful and not others
They might not be doing it just to show how perfect their art is, they simply enjoy it
Dude, you’re the one who’s looking for attention by making drama on every comment section
Honestly, internet isn’t the place for you if you’re gonna act like that
You’re not an artist either, so please don’t act like one
If you can’t understand the difference between criticism and making people feel bad because of their art, you’re not even near being an artist and here you’re talking about some bad shading techniques?
Real artists understand it’s not okay to talk lik that about someone’s artwork
Honestly as an artist I can make sure I’d be super insulted if someone talked like that about my art :/ this isn’t constructive criticism, it’s just being rude and immature and doesn’t help any artist at all, despite the fact that they might not be doing it for the sake of showing off their great artistic talents, they might b doing it just for fun!
But you can’t say ‘your art sucks and it’s terrible, change it because I want to’ is super disrespectful towards an artist
Really
Here you’re talking shit again
While you don’t pay for the original work
>Comes to stalk my shit and then blocks me after sperguing
Applause.
I'm not even clicking this stuff to expand what you wrote if it's just ramblings to a wall if I can't answer to it.
Quote: But you can’t say ‘your art sucks and it’s terrible, change it because I want to’ is super disrespectful towards an artist
And arrogant. Who am I to tell someone to change their art. I can like it or not, I can critique it or not, but to tell someone to stop doing something you don't like about something you don't pay for/commission/support is some real conceit and arrogance. There's lots of art I like and lots I don't, so what? The artist didn't create it for ME--well, unless I commissioned the art and paid for it. Then it's for me. :)
Stop replying to this person
This person has been causing drama and annoyance not only for the team but for everyone and insults anyone with a different opinion
It’s just a child looking for attention and that’s why reply to trolls won’t work
That’s the point
But the real problem is that this person that keeps annoying everyone, just wants attention and make drama
So the best way is to ignore him/her
I honestly feel so important being referred to in the intro page :')
Honestly it is disrespectful to color pages, the author didn't want them color and you're so cocky thinking you're providing an update when you're not.
your coloring as I said before, decent at most. I'm sorry you got super triggered cause no matter how much you complain and bitch and attack me you know I'm right.
Anyone saying the colored pages are OMG SUPERB PIECES OF Art is lying and sucking up cause of the mentality that you need to suck scanlators epenis. This is a fact, I saw some coloring for another project with yellow and green background, wew.... You can't hard shadow to save your life, pretty much all soft shadows and burns.
It's not bad but don't come and defend it like it's the art of our gen cause it's not.
Anyway I just legit laughed at your message.
Like I said, practice your coloring instead of getting triggered, that's gonna be better for you.
Also not trolling, I was giving my opinion and the scanlator and her friends came at me so I just kept at it. I feel they were being the inmature ones but, being on my side means scanlators gonna get triggered and no scans....
fuck this mentality really.