amazing story but a bit unsatisfied

microscopicdingdong July 12, 2019 3:42 pm

i really loved this webtoon but as i was reading i couldn’t help but feel unsatisfied with how it dealt with the real siwon’s death. he was r*ped and bullied tremendously not only from the people at school but his own brother. and the fact that he killed himself bc no one was there that he could rely on rlly fcking sucks. joohoon (the blonde crazy fcker) even played a major role in his death, yet he didn’t receive a punishment which makes me angrier the more i think about it. even the confrontation with his younger brother felt unsatisfactory. i just wish the story expanded more on the real siwon’s redemption.

Responses
    ral July 17, 2019 5:47 am

    yea I understand how you feel XD there are still some holes that could be filled/addressed. It's interesting b/c Siwon had friends so you'd think they cared? and it seemed like the whole bullying thing was a fairly recent thing? (minus the 3 months in a coma). But I'm not sure the exact time line, its a bit confusing.

    Anon July 17, 2019 5:15 pm

    I think the fact that the police didn't do a follow up, the insurance (trucker's) didn't do a follow up, nor even his parents to a follow up on him getting hit, should be what is sad. The kid fell through the cracks.

    However, it seems he was at peace with his decision when he passed. It is described by his smile and that he closed his eyes, he looked content with his decision. I actually have to wonder, if he was the one who chose to do the body switch, and that the smile was because he knew that two someones who had had equally terrible lives were going to have someone to hold onto, and keep the afloat/sane.

    microscopicdingdong July 17, 2019 10:19 pm
    I think the fact that the police didn't do a follow up, the insurance (trucker's) didn't do a follow up, nor even his parents to a follow up on him getting hit, should be what is sad. The kid fell through the ... Anon

    yes i agree the police and his parents both should’ve done a proper investigation to find out what really happened to him. but i felt really uncomfortable with how it showed his death. sure he was smiling before he died, but to me it seemed really like lonely and melancholy one. i don’t think the real siwon would’ve noticed the body switch especially during those circumstances. the scene overall reminded of how pitifully lonely he was. i just wished the author would’ve given his situation more thought, don't get me wrong i liked how the second siwon and woojin reunited. but i felt that the author made a character suffer so much only for the sake of the plot and disregard him in the end without a proper redemption.

    microscopicdingdong July 17, 2019 10:21 pm
    yea I understand how you feel XD there are still some holes that could be filled/addressed. It's interesting b/c Siwon had friends so you'd think they cared? and it seemed like the whole bullying thing was a fa... ral

    yeah it was recent so it kinda irritates me how his parents could just let that incident go without a proper explanation. T_T

    Anon July 18, 2019 5:26 am

    I have also wondered if it isn't a round about way of the author making the statement that no one is going to fight for yourself, except for you. Suicide is a (horrible, tragic) way out, but you may not get any justice. There will not be any glory. Life will go on for everyone else (whether they want it to or not).

    ral July 18, 2019 6:03 am
    I have also wondered if it isn't a round about way of the author making the statement that no one is going to fight for yourself, except for you. Suicide is a (horrible, tragic) way out, but you may not get an... Anon

    Thats actually a good point you bring about. It makes sense since Taemin is all about standing up for himself and to some extent others.

    ral July 18, 2019 6:05 am

    I was also going to add, now that I reread it, the video footage they have, if I'm not mistaken, the Johoon (sp?) guy and the others who did all that stuff to Siwon are on there. They could just take the footage to the police and get them all arrested. Unless we think they were recorded (since we saw them) but their faces werent? still pretty good evidence...

    looololol July 19, 2019 3:01 am
    I was also going to add, now that I reread it, the video footage they have, if I'm not mistaken, the Johoon (sp?) guy and the others who did all that stuff to Siwon are on there. They could just take the footag... ral

    but it’s an accurate depiction of korean society tho. like it’s so conservative that it would be very difficult for a man to talk abt being rped and it’s even worse that he was rped by other men. bullying isn’t really taken all that seriously, and suicide unfortunately is a common occurrence among teens. :/ I’m not saying it’s super unrealistic for him to report such an incident, but it makes sense (ofc it isn’t right tho korean society should be better)

    ral July 19, 2019 4:44 am
    but it’s an accurate depiction of korean society tho. like it’s so conservative that it would be very difficult for a man to talk abt being rped and it’s even worse that he was rped by other men. bullying... looololol

    Yea I suppose realistically that is true, there and in other places as well. But I suppose since it wasn't Taemin who got hurt (but rather the guy before) that it would be too much effort to go after the bad guys as well. Its just too bad that kid just kind of got left behind, but I suppose it makes sense because how would you explain Taemin is in Siwons body lol.