So many unsolved mysteries in D.gray-man

I think his name is really Allen. We do not know his last name though. Nea said that his friend "Allen" was watching over his memory. I believe he somehow turned back time on himself and got some Innocence during the process. But with that lost his memories and knows nothing about his past with Nea anymore.

But didn't mana called the dog allen?? And didn't the dog just talked to mana ??
Σ( ￣□￣||)

Yeah that could be it. Also I do believe that Allen has the heart. I've been thinking that sense it killed a lion's heart and Allen brought it back together from us in mist.

Isn´t it pretty much confirmed that Allen has the heart. I mean Apocryphos was a real good indicator. And they way he talked... for me that was convincing. Also in the new chapter they stated, that "now" was the perfect time to kill the earl, and Nea is half of the Millenniumearl, so if I would be the heart, I would "take over" one half of the Earl. If that makes any sense.

That's the theory that everyone is going with. I, on the other hand, believe in a completely different theory.

I think the whole, turn back in time thing is just to far fetched. There has been anything indication that that is the case.

On the other hand, there is an indication that Allen is a completely different character from Red. I believe that Red is just an innocent bystander and just happen by chance to meet Mana. Meaning that Red is not Allen.

Assuming that Nea is inside the Dog, and the Dog just talked to Mana subconsciously in the recent chapter, I'd say that Allen must have been force to transfer himself and Nea into the Dog.

After the Dog died, Cross transfer Nea into Red. And Nea must have thought that Allen transfer himself into Red as well without realizing that Allen died as a Dog and it was Cross who transfer Nea into Red and not Allen.

True thats another mystery!! (๑•ㅂ•)و✧

They haven't explain that yet but there are hints of it.

In Chapter 228 when Red meets Timcanpy, Red ask if he could be friend with Rimcanpy. Cross mention that Red was already friend with Timcanpy long ago. This indicates that Red is Allen because Timcanpy originally belong to Nea and Nea passed it onto Allen.

In additional to that scene, Cross mention that he wanted to kill Timcanpy. The scene hinted that Cross wants nothing to do with Nea's plot. But like Mother said, killing Tim won't change the fact that he is involve now that he knows the truth. Whether he likes it or not, he will be entangled in this mess because people will be coming after him now that he knows the truth. Thus, he needs to choose a side.

Knowing that there is something fishy about the Order and not wanting to join the Noah, Cross must have reluctantly decided to side with Nea. I think he was pull into this mess without him having a choice. The reason why he's helping Nea isn't anything like companionship or love. It's more of a business relation. That is why when Links ask why Nea team up with Cross, Nea reply in a business manner that it was neccesary.

And seeing how the Cardinal is an Apocryphos, I think it is safe to assume that the Order is rule by these Human Innocence. And knowing that they're Innocence, I'd assume that if an apostle level their Innocence enough, their innocent will take a will of their own and become a Human Innocence. Just take a look at Crown Clown. The same goes with Lenalee's Innocence. They're taking measures of their own accord without the command of the apostles who wields them.

It may very well take the consciousness of the apostles like that of the Noah Stigmata. Cause as we all know, the power of the Noah isn't all that different from the powers of the Innocence. The fact that both the Millennium Earl and Red has similar looking weapons and the fact that the Millennium Earl has an outer shell cloak like that of Crown Clown is proof that the Innocence may as well be the equivalent of a Noah Stigmata.