You have to understand that athy didn’t have a father in her past life so he’s been her only dad and it was such a strong bond, I don’t think anyone would want to just let that go.
I know and I respect that. Athy just wants to have fatherly love and she can't help it. But I'm saying this because her want for fatherly love is what is making her feel so horrible! She can do what she thinks is right but what I think is right is to leave. No matter how horrible it feels, I doubt it would be as horrible as having a new kind of hurt everytime you look at your father knowing that he probably won't remember you! And knowing that there would be someone else taking away the only feeling of fatherly love you ever knew of. I'm just stating my opinion but at the end of the day, as long as Athy doesn't regret anything I'm fine with her decision. Although I do feel frustrated that Claude doesn't remember her.
Athy, just leave him. Like for good. He doesn't deserve you! Claude should just die! Because I can't take it anymore! How can you still stay with someone if all they are gonna do is hurt you! I don't get you. I know you love your dad but he isn't the same person! It would be more rational of you to try and look for Lucas instead! Ask him to help you! And make it known to Claude that you could care less if he drops down the face of the earth! You ate way too nice for your own good! And why can't you see what a burden Jennette's idiocy is becoming to you! It hurts you more than it heals! Just leave them! You don't need them! If Claude doesn't want, you shouldn't want him either! It's breaking all of our damn hearts! The fact that Claude can't remember you is tearing us readers apart! And I swear to God if I ever get my hands on him, I will slap his face so hard he gets a concussion!!!