I think your first theory is really interesting, but I have a feeling Beatrice body was taken over by Raeliana (or someone else, because she had the same symptoms as MC), that's how she knows MC swaped soul
And if Beatrice is really Raeliana, she couldnt plot to kill herself before the swap
Did I make sense? Or was confusing? My english is not my main language e.e
What you say makes sense. I think your theory is reasonable.
But then what exactly happened to original Beatrice? Where did her soul go after Raeliana's soul go into her body? Do you think she was the person (black shadow) that pushed the MC to another world in the beginning?
I think my biggest question to the theory that Beatrice has a Raeliana's soul inside is how did she know that Beatrice was supposed to be with the Noah? And other things (it looks like she knows a lot).
Also actually I think that if she planned to swap soul with Beatrice from the beginning then it's possible to plan to kill her body before doing it (because if she planned to exchange souls with the Beatrice, then the soul of Beatrice was supposed to end up in Raeliana's body and she would be the only person that knew about the change, so maybe she wanted to kill her after exchanging souls?).
What if the symptoms in Beatrice's case are for the different reason? She said that she wanted to change her fate like something would happen to her so maybe the world itself rejects her because she is not main character anymore but MC's friend (and MC's friend was supposed to die in this world or Raeliana took her place as MC so she is not needed anymore)?
Sorry for the long reply. I hope it makes sense. Actually I think your theory is really good. I just like to think of many theories and see which one of them was right. Well sometimes none of them are right, but well... ╮(￣▽￣)╭
That's a interesting point! Another theory I thought was what if beatrice was taken over by someone of the same world as mc? That would explain why she wanted to kill Raeliana and knew she was supposed to be with Noah. And maybe she went to the world the same time as MC, explaning how she knew about the soul swap
We know Raeliana was supposed to die poisoned by francis and it was an order from the guy who had the sister killed (forgot his name e.e) and he received those order from Beatrice, so thats why i dont think Raeliana could plan to kill herself before the swap
Oh, just came up with a new theory! Maybe Beatrice went to the fortuneteller and thats how she found out what was suppose to be her fate, but since MC didn't die, it didnt happen and thats why she want to kill her so she can finally get Noah? Or maybe Raeliana somehow found out about it and went to the dark fortuneteller to avoid it or to swap body with Beatrice, but somehow things went wrong?
But that don't change the question: Where Beatrice soul went then? Who were the shadow person who pushed MC? And what exactly happened to the dark fortuneteller Raeliana was visiting?
So many question (〜￣△￣)〜
And no problem, all make sense and are really interesting! And I enjoying coming up with new theories too ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~
Your theories are really interesting!
You're right Beatrice being from MC's world explains her knowledge about the events in the future. Oh, in that case what if soul in Beatrice is the dark shadow who pushed MC. (I think I have to many different theories about black shadow xD)
And what if she contacted Langston(the guy with sister killed by Brooks) by letters and/or didn't show her face to him? (I mean Brooks approached Raeliana after getting orders from Langston and when the MC becomes Raeliana they are already engaged. And that would mean that Langston received the order to kill Raeliana before the soul exchange happened.) After becoming Raeliana MC had only her original memories (I'll call it soul memories xD) and didn't know what real Raeliana was up to. So if Raeliana (or someone from MC's world) became Beatrice then wouldn't it be similar for her? How would that person know about the plan of killing Raeliana in detail if it was real Beatrice who planned that and another soul, without Beatrice's soul memories, was now in her body? (We know that in the book it was written only about Brooks). I just thought about it but what if it's black magician (the one that original Raeliana went to and who was killed because of king's concubine) that is now in Beatrice's body?(⊙…⊙ ) Beatrice now seems to know some black magic (but well Raeliana could learn it from magician).
Your new theory about fortune teller is really interesting! It explains a lot of things.
Right, so many questions...
I really enjoy exchanging ideas with you! (⌒▽⌒)
Thats what I thought! What if the talk they had before pushing MC was about the book and she made some pact with a witch, but had to sacrifice someone and thats why killed mc in the original world? Well, actually this looks unrealistic, but its a possibilite xD
Oooh, that way its possible! But what if the lost memories happened only to MC? Because original Raeliana visited the black magician and could have made it happens only to the one got her body? And probably she couldn't have known if the olds memories would remain or not
Humm, that's interesting! But I think Beatrice know black magic because she was adopted by the author of the back vestal theory! That what I thought when I read this part:
http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/the_reason_why_raeliana_ended_up_at_the_duke_s_mansion/nto/mpn_chapter-2205024/pg-11/
I'm enjoying a lot too ヾ(☆▽☆)
Well maybe not that unrealistic because the conversation clearly ended up by MC's death and transfer to another world. It's also really possible that they were talking about the novel. Like in this type of story (MC going to the world of novel/manga/game) I always wonder how they remember the story with so many details. Like is it the last thing they read before they crossed to that world? For example I'm not sure if I could tell the story of a novel I read 3 years in great detail. XD
Sorry I accidentally pressed 'post it' before I finished writing so this is second part (￣∇￣")
About only MC losing Raeliana's soul memories, well it's definitely possible.
You're right! (I actually forgot about black vestal xD) It's definitely possible.
I think they remember clearly because is a novel/game/manga they just read before dying in the original world
Im enjoying quite a lot this type of genre, so reading lots that are similar :3
Same here, I'm also reading a lot that are similar. The really popular among them is villainess motive I think.
I think the ones that MC turns back time and change her live are also quite interesting~
And some are really cute ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~
Oh, this type of turning back in time I think I haven't read yet. Any recommendation?
I'm reading some of that type:
The Abandoned Empress - strong MC, this one is quite controversial (looking on comments) there is one big spoiler that almost everyone talks about in the comments (who the MC will be with). (⊙…⊙ )
The Duchess with an Empty Soul - this one is quite cute. MC can summon a cute creatures.
The Villainess Reverses the Hourglass - step sister problem. (I think the idea is interesting because in most of villainess stories the MC has a goal not to be bad, but here she decided to be a villainess).
Revenge of a Fierce Princess - MC chooses bad guy, gets killed (in a really brutal way) and decides to get revenge. (Tbh I'm not sure if I recommend this one because at the beginning the story is quite interesting but from some point I get the feeling that it's a bit forced). ╮(￣▽￣)╭
The Imperial Master Above - this one is shounen ai. (It's just the beginning but I'm quite looking forward to how the story will go).
Just in case the story before turning the time tends to be tragic.
Thank you! All of them seems interesting ε=ε=(ノ≧∇≦)ノ
You're welcome~ ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~
After chapter 121
Just my random thoughts on events and a strange theory, I'm writing it to not forget about it. ╮(￣▽￣)╭
In the story it seems that the Beatrice was behind the Brooks and Langston (like hiring Langston to kill Raeliana and Langston knew Brooks who was responsible for the death of his sister, so he used it) and she also manipulated Vivian later (giving her the gem and saying it'll do something to Raeliana's face but the truth was it was supposed to kill her).
So what if Beatrice was mastermind behind Raeliana's death even in "original novel"? And her original plan was to kill Raeliana by using Brooks (like it happened in the novel) but because of the soul crossing from another world she had to make changes to her original plans?
Also maybe even stranger thought but what if originally Raeliana was supposed to be with Noah, but Beatrice somehow knew about it and then she thought about the plan to take her place (the things that happened in the novel), but then Raeliana somehow knew and went to the black magician (? The one that "committed suicide" because of helping the king's concubine) and the soul crossed from another world and Raeliana got together with Noah like she was supposed to? <this sounds to complicated to be true I suppose>
And a question why Beatrice was not on the list of students in school she was supposed to go to? Like even if you drop out they should still have the record of her going there, right?