You know, I just realized that the readers are acting like the readers of the Lovely Princ...

For those who had read the novel they know that she Is a little bit sketchy, and you cant really tell if she Is inocente or plain stupid or manupulative or a psychopath... buuuuuut i get your point she havent dont anything bad besides having trash, the thing that not even rats would eat for a dad and a poor excuse of man as an "uncle" AND the fact that she was raised to belive she is claude's daugther isnt her fault so we cant really blame a CHILD for bealiving what she Is told.

Is like we bealiving that a fat man in a red bright suit come down the fireplace to leave us presents, i mean how stupid that sound but we still bealive because the people around us TOLD US that it was like that. Is the same with Janette

Sorry didnt mean to leave a long answer (￣∇￣")

I think most people don't like her because if the circumstances. Claude lost his memory and Jeanette can take away his love from Athy. Fans are basically being careful and jealous for Athy ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Claude is a horrible, broken man for not loving both daughters EQUALLY. Jeanette is in Anthy’s old situation, the roles are merely switched.

Jeanette isn't even his daughter why in hell should he love her the same as Athy (〜￣△￣)〜

But Claude THOUGHT she was his daughter at one point, right? Regardless if she's his daughter or not anyway, no child deserves to be treated so coldly. Not Anthy, not Jeanette. I said what I said.

Nah, he knew it all along that Jeanette's not his. Your point is true though, he shouldn't be cold to a child

Nope that happened in the novel as far as the story goes now there was no mention of Jeanette to Claude yet so to him she's not related only Athy knows so it doesn't make any sense to me that he would treat her like a daughter at all ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Fine, he doesn’t have to treat her like a daughter. But can you justify him treating a CHILD this way? Oh come on, when you have kids that can’t swim and they fall into a river, I would hope someone UNRELATED to them would help . The thing missing here is compassion. Idk why ur trying to justify this. He doesn’t have to love her but damn it took athy begging him to have him lift his hand to save her smh.

isn't he a tyrant - ish king though? why would he care about some random girl drowning

Omg!! Finally, someone who brought this up like srsly, this already tells that most reader here just plainly cares just for Athy and have no what so ever remorse for almost anyone. Like I am so surprised on why there is little to none on hate for the whites or claude. Like it was shown in the novel, athy past life that she was killed by her own dad even before she was proven guilty like what kind of men is that? He calls himself an Emperor yet act like a selfish bastard that value people's lives of an insect, killing them or threatening as he please. Just because jennette ain't his child whatsoever have no excuse for his shitty behaviour. In fact, those who are so caring and defensive for athy should equally hate Claude and Mr white, why? Because claude who killed athy and white who still causing this shitty drama for his unquenchable greed ain't getting any shit from the readers. But nope you can clearly see who just hating on her because she is the second female lead that they view as a threat even though the manga clearly shows who the hell is the main culprit. This chapter just shows how much of a trash claude is, remember he killed all the people in the jewel palace cuz his love of his life died? Pathetic.Although i do understand his circumstances but can't believe he stoop this low and more unbelievable that some praise and glorified that Claude didn't want to save jennette lol. Srsly this is just sad.

sorry i down voted ┗( T﹏T )┛ You brought up an interesting point with that parallel. in short people only ever want to see the protagonists side of things and want to willfully remain ignorant of anything else that would possibly put more grey into the situation and make more then one character sympathetic?

Yup exactly

Yep, sure the same went for Athy right? Remember in the earlier chapters where he took his silly time before saving her? That was the EXACT same position jennette was just in. My point still stands. He is a cruel broken man.

Lol, y'all forgetting that the first thing we learned about him was that he killed his own daughter (now Athy again) and felt no remorse even after learning she was innocent? For a daughter her, learns later (before he kills Athy) that is not his own?

I started this cuz you said Claude have to treat both "daughters" equally. And as I previously said he doesn't have to and that's that. Your later point stands but my point stands too ლ(´ڡ`ლ)

Uhhh wrong person. I never said that