By any chance,

✿ ᒪᓰᒪ૪ ᕈᓰᗴ ✿ November 28, 2020 4:12 pm

Does Leo know she's a female?

Responses
    Nanashi November 28, 2020 4:16 pm

    Not yet, I think.

    ✿ ᒪᓰᒪ૪ ᕈᓰᗴ ✿ November 28, 2020 4:19 pm
    Not yet, I think. Nanashi

    Really? but strangely he treats her like a lover!!

    Nanashi November 28, 2020 4:38 pm
    Really? but strangely he treats her like a lover!! ✿ ᒪᓰᒪ૪ ᕈᓰᗴ ✿

    She thinks so too.

    archi November 28, 2020 9:36 pm

    There is a hint that she ran into him as a woman when she was drunk. So he does know.

    Nanashi November 28, 2020 9:54 pm
    There is a hint that she ran into him as a woman when she was drunk. So he does know. archi

    Oooo I don't remember that, when was it?

    archi November 28, 2020 10:21 pm

    It was chapter 1, right after she got into the knights, when she was trying to be average, not draw attention to herself and her Estien disguise was still very new.

    Nanashi November 28, 2020 11:54 pm
    It was chapter 1, right after she got into the knights, when she was trying to be average, not draw attention to herself and her Estien disguise was still very new. archi

    Ohh thanks !

    Nanashi November 29, 2020 12:03 am
    It was chapter 1, right after she got into the knights, when she was trying to be average, not draw attention to herself and her Estien disguise was still very new. archi

    Um I just reread chapter 1 twice and up to chapter 5 again but there was no mention of anyone finding out about her being a female.
    Only Tonton found out she was hiding her skills (swordsmanship) but no mention of her gender being revealed to anyone.
    Maybe perhaps in a novel? Idk

    diveien November 29, 2020 12:14 am
    Um I just reread chapter 1 twice and up to chapter 5 again but there was no mention of anyone finding out about her being a female. Only Tonton found out she was hiding her skills (swordsmanship) but no mention... Nanashi

    yeah I don't think he does. He's just being super friendly 'cause he likes her, as a him, wants to be buds but doesn't realize yet that it's a bit more than that? Or at least that's how it goes in these cross dressing kind of stories

    ✿ ᒪᓰᒪ૪ ᕈᓰᗴ ✿ November 29, 2020 9:39 am
    It was chapter 1, right after she got into the knights, when she was trying to be average, not draw attention to herself and her Estien disguise was still very new. archi

    Oh now that you mention it! There was a scene like that but they cut it off and didn’t mention anything about it anymore!

    Akumajona November 29, 2020 11:49 am
    It was chapter 1, right after she got into the knights, when she was trying to be average, not draw attention to herself and her Estien disguise was still very new. archi

    Oh, that would be wonderfull! That would nake so much sence! The best course for the story!

    Akumajona November 29, 2020 12:38 pm
    There is a hint that she ran into him as a woman when she was drunk. So he does know. archi

    Ch 1 and ch 7 when he makes his. Proposal and asks about estella. His. Reaction to it all...

    diveien November 29, 2020 3:00 pm
    Ch 1 and ch 7 when he makes his. Proposal and asks about estella. His. Reaction to it all... Akumajona

    I'm sorry but I re-read those chapters and there's absolutely no indication that the prince knows that Estien is Estella. In ch 1 Estella says she crossed path with "someone she shouldn't have had to" and the blurred image seems of the prince, but it doesn't say why or how or anything that happened for that matter. Just that he was scary. - no indication that he thought she was a she. Ch 7 he's out to convince a guy to pretend he's a girl and engaged to him to boot... yeah his reactions and his whole behavior is fishy as hell, but not indicating in any way he knows or even suspect he's Estella. The fact that there is an Estella and an Estien is a matter of public record as Estella finds out that her father recorded both names at birth, the prince likely knew from there. If that is what passes as "clues" that Leo knows he's actually her, that's just poor writing.

    Akumajona November 29, 2020 9:51 pm
    I'm sorry but I re-read those chapters and there's absolutely no indication that the prince knows that Estien is Estella. In ch 1 Estella says she crossed path with "someone she shouldn't have had to" and the b... diveien

    Well, their "fatefull meeting" was the one in the forest, so the drunk meeting can't be a foreshadowing to that. It would have been, if the prince recognized estien and spoke of that. But he didn't. So the meeting in ch1 is a foreshadowing to something else in future chapters. My guess- it will be reveaked kater, that drunk estella /estien did or said something, that influenced the prince. And in ch7, the questions the prince asks and his reaction to estellas answers... Well,, he already did a very thorough background check on him. Probably put two and two together and then confirmed his guesses. This is all speculation, but often things are hinted or foreshadowed only slightly. So that either a very attentive reader will notice or when reading a story for the second time, or third, or so on.
    Thx for coming to my ted talk? *)

    diveien November 29, 2020 10:21 pm
    Well, their "fatefull meeting" was the one in the forest, so the drunk meeting can't be a foreshadowing to that. It would have been, if the prince recognized estien and spoke of that. But he didn't. So the meet... Akumajona

    " that drunk estella /estien did or said something, that influenced the prince." I can see that being something, but both this and the behaviour in answering are not indicative that he knows he's a she. As you yourself mentioned " often things are hinted or foreshadowed only slightly" and this is done with clear hints, not just open ended imagination and wishful thinking on the side of the reader. The weird behaviour on the sandoffish answers in no way indicate that he thinks he's a she... just that he's put off by the man he hired to be his fiancee, being colder to him than to the guard he assigned to her. that's all