I think it was her dad the second mage who wished she would keep her memory. And act UK al...

He caused her death but that's OK? I don't know if he was under a spell in the previous life or not you can't forgive him.

He had his own reasons, and he even returned time, and made himself suffer too in both lives. U might not forgive bc of death, but i can bc he returned her. I mean i dod not completely forgave him, but at least i do not hate him.

It is still not revealed who requested to turn back time tho how are u sure its the father? And he still caused her death so i dunno if I can forgive him. Maybe later if he really had a very good reason otherwise errr..

tho i do despise the father for not even showing his daughter love and affection until her last moments before she got turned back into time, i am also hoping for more character development from her father (๑•ㅂ•)و✧

YES! and also sincerely apologizing to her for neglecting her all these years. And i still don't forgive him for believing a complete stranger over his own daughter smh

Why i am sure it is bc he had nightmares abt his past and forget what was done after waking up. And i am not sayi g to completely forgive him, but i am saying i do not hate him. And yeah maybe he believed at some point tk stranger, but he was surely loved his daughter but could not show his affection. We can observe it even now, when he still can not remeber his past he restricts himself. I pity him, but do not forgive him completely, bc he caused her death and that is fact, no matter he suffered too or not. I just dont hate him. But these comments abt they really like the view of father suffering...i dislike them. Yeah, again i can not totally forgive him, but would not say i like how he is suffering, but he deserve them

Something like 'regret' means 'it is too late'.

I agree that the dad is the second person. But it doesn't change the fact that he hurt and traumatized her mentally really bad. The time has reversed but she has memories and the phantom sensations of being cut at the neck 'To forgive' is too late for him cuz he has already done the deed and had her killed. May be the kind MC will give him secomd change. But untill she gives him, I will strongly dislike him.

Well...u know...he had a choice to not even give the right to have memories of past life. But he gave...meaning he was ready to suffer and he is really feels bad abt what he did and so by this second life he is paying for his deed. With already this i can not hate him. And i will not untill daughter forgives him bc kight untill the end she would not know the truth, but i will wait untill he had a real reason to drive his daughter to death...which will be a hard thing to do...bc...u know...anyway, i can not hate him.

So giving her memories of her death is a good thing now and won't cause her suffering? Nope. He doesn't feel bad about his deed either. I assure you. Even if he did he shouldn't be surprised that a girl he's only ever treated coldly in the memories he DOES have is turning against him.

Ok. I just understand u dont simply wnat to comprehend what i am saying and only want see the negative side of a character. I am telling it is not like he is evil and so on, but u only want to see that. He is not a typical villainess with only aim to domimate but u wish to see that in him. So, no point to continue arguing with yall, if only me trying to understand ur will.

Oh no. I am not saying he is an evil character. I am saying that he has done the 'deed' which is 'killing her'. Even if the situation is manipulated by the fake daughter, he never TRIED to understand mc and act as a father. So even if he is not evil, he is the one who hurt her. Killing someone is a crime, especially killing our own bllod cruely is a hideous act.

So unless the person herself forgives her, I will not even give a 1% sympathy to him. Just as if mc forgives her father, I will have no choice but to try to understand him.

Oh. Okay, thats ur choice.
My choice is that i can not hate him tho